Several students and parents stepped forward at the North Allegheny School Board’s work session this month to defend inclusion of “The Hate U Give” in the ninth grade English curriculum.

“The Hate U Give,” by Angie Thomas, tells the story of a Black teenager, Starr Carter, who witnesses a white police officer killing her unarmed friend during a traffic stop. It was added to the English Language Arts curriculum in 2019 and had been piloted by a group of ninth-grade teachers for two years prior to that, said Brandi Smith, public relations and communications specialist for the district.

Some parents anonymously told a local news Facebook site that they planned to protest the book at a board meeting, objecting to cursing and drug use in the novel. Nobody opposing the book spoke at the March 17 meeting.

Parents were forewarned about the book’s content, Ms. Smith said.

Advertise with us

“At the beginning of the unit, families received communication regarding this novel, which stated themes, situations and language presented in the book were of a mature nature. The communication also shared the commitment to addressing the content of the book in a professional and appropriate way,” she said. “Families were given the opportunity to opt-out of the novel and read another book in its place. No families opted out of reading the novel.”

“The Hate U Give” was added to the unit of study on “bias” and replaced “To Kill a Mockingbird,” which was moved to another unit of study. The district removed “A Separate Peace” and “The Gospel According to Larry” after the 2019 curriculum review, she added.

Ms. Smith said the district aims to provide students with “diverse and engaging reading experiences.”

The five speakers who defended the book — all of whom read passages — said that diverse voices are needed in the district.

Student Lamees Subeir read a portion that discusses “the talk” where Black parents tell their children how to behave when interacting with police — actions such as always keeping hands visible.

Advertise with us

“This is something that North Allegheny students never have to do, but Black people must be taught this lesson in order to survive. … This is a lesson that NA students need to hear,” Lamees said.

Lamees added that there are “very few issues about Black struggle in the curriculum outside of slavery.”

“Please do not remove this book from the curriculum because it might be sensitive. Sensitive just means that people do not want to talk about it.”

The book shows the “urban and suburban divide” because Starr lives in a poor, mostly Black neighborhood, but she attends a mostly white suburban prep school, said Avery Neely.

“The issues discussed in this book ... are objective truth,” she said. “What is the role of an educator if not to make sense of the world for the students?”

Advertise with us

Christina Kotchanka read a passage where Starr is interacting with two friends, one white and one Asian. The white friend does not understand how her words and actions affect her other friends.

“Whether we realize or not, microaggressions are commonplace at NA,” she said.

Parent Melinda Wedde said that novels like “The Hate U Give” “opens the door to conversations about racism. … It is important in a predominately white district to educate students about racism.”

According to North Allegheny’s November 2020 enrollment report, the district is 73.6% white, followed by Asian at 18.91%, multiracial at 2.89%, Hispanic at 2.73% and Black at 1.67%.

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.