It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of the wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, depending on who’s asking.

When Sharpsburg borough council voted down a proposed anitdiscrimination ordinance 4-3 in October, the community’s LGBTQ residents and their supporters were shocked, indignant, hurt and surprised. They let council know it during the November Zoom meeting on Nov. 19. After all their neighbors, Etna Borough had just approved 8-1 an LGBTQ-inclusive ordinance two days earlier.

“Why should the people of Sharpsburg have to go elsewhere,” asked Carrie Tongarm, who is a lawyer for a local utility. She said the aim of the ordinance was to create a safe space for all Sharpsburg residents. “Discrimination happens every day and the LGBTQ community is vulnerable.”

And such laws are only local. Etna became the 61st municipality in Pennsylvania, the fourth in Allegheny County to pass such a law. There is no such law at either the county or state level. Council member Jessica Semler spearheaded the ordinance as an openly queer official. “In Etna, we go by the slogan, ‘Etna is for Everyone,’” she said a post from the Etna Community Organization.

Advertise with us

“I ran for borough council as an openly queer woman, because representation matters. In the face of federal and state government not doing enough in the face of continued structural inequalities, legal discrimination, homopobia and transphobia, it is imperative that local government step up and fill that gap,” she said. “I’m so appreciative for the generosity of time and knowledge my fellow more experienced council members contributed to make it possible and make this ordinance the best it could be.”

Etna councilwoman Megan Tunon said she is proud to be part of the vote in a recent FaceBook post. She credited Jessica Semler for her “thoughtful and thorough work to craft this ordinance and to get our council behind it.”

Sharpsburg and Etna boroughs - along with their cohort Millvale - have been working together for years as part of a larger group to create culture, sustainability and opportunity in their neighborhoods. Ms. Reno is the president of Sharpsburg Neighborhood Organization as well as council and she was one of the council members who voted for the antidiscrimination policy in November.

For her, it was personal. She has a sister who identifies as LGBQT who she hardly sees because she moved out of Pennsylvania because neither the state nor Allegheny County have yet to pass laws that prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation. “I’m eager to vote in support of this ordinance tonight,” she said at the October meeting but she was disappointed. So was Adrianne Laing, who worked with Etna Council on the ordinance. “We are a safe, welcoming community,” Ms. Laing said. In addition, new council member Brad Truman voted for the ordinance.

Greg Domian, Jonathan Jaso, Karen Pilarski-Pastor and Joe Simbari voted it down. They said they were going on advice from the borough’s legal counsel who told them it would open them up to litigation. Several also said the ordinance had no teeth as it was written to offer protection to those claiming discrimination.

Advertise with us

“There’s not a member on council who doesn’t want to say yes,” said Mr. Simbari. “You’re preaching to the choir. We want to say yes. The way it’s written it’s not going to fly. We’re going to get it right and pass a nondiscrimination ordinance everybody can be proud of.”

“I agree with Mr. Simbari,” said Mr. Domain. “I also pay attention to what our solicitor said. My big concern is to protect the town from legal costs. I don’t think that’s asking too much.”

But those in favor who spoke at the November meeting disagreed. They said the ordinance could protect someone who was discriminated against based on their lifestyle by landlords and employers in the borough.

Kyle Webster, who is not a resident but the general counsel for human resources of Action Housing, a nonprofit provider of affordable housing and support services for Sounthwestern Pennsylvania residents, said he’d share his legal expertise with the council.

Kayla Portis, a fourth generation Sharpsburg resident who is raising her family in her hometown now asked that council follow Etna’s lead: “Please open your heart and minds and try again,” she said.

Advertise with us

And after some discussion, that’s the plan. Some adjustments will be made to the proposed ordinance. Instead of facing a five-member panel, those accused of discrimination will receive a non-threatening letter from the borough and be represented by a mediator.”

Mr. Thurman suggested the council should seat the commission and choose the mediator and agreed any hearings be conducted in a non-threatening way.

Ms. Reno also agreed with this plan. A neutral arbitrator who is not on the commission would speak for anyone accused of discrimination. Also, she said, elected officials will not be allowed to serve on the commission or hold the role of mediator.

So during the rest of November until the next Sharpsburg council meeting, which is set for Dec. 17 at 6:30 in a Zoom format, council members will work with community members and staff to revise the ordinance into one that is fair and defensible for all.

Rita Michel, freelance writer, suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.