Nick Fazzoni is the 21st century success story Butler wants, and is increasingly making common.
The 35-year-old lifelong Butler resident graduated from Butler Senior High School, Butler County Community College and Slippery Rock University.
He made a brief foray into corporate life, working local jobs for Verizon and Cars.com before co-founding Butler Brew Works on Main Street.
The process of turning his home-brew hobby into a serious business venture began in 2010. But it took almost six years before the brewery opened its doors, something Mr. Fazzoni attributed to city officials not understanding how a brewery would function.
Now, the business is an example of the innovative economic ideas bubbling up in Butler.
“The city has to reinvent itself,” Mr. Fazzoni said. “It looks like it’s moving in the direction of arts and culture and nightlife.”
Butler still is recovering from its loss of industry in the late 20th century. Gone are plentiful steel industry jobs, and in their place other Butler hallmarks — including those related to arts, culture and nightlife — have helped energize the city of about 13,000 residents.

Only a few blocks from Butler Brew Works is a competitor, Reclamation Brewing Co., that opened in 2015. It is co-owned, notably, by 31-year-old Butler Mayor Ben Smith.
“For the most part, people are very open and accepting of new things in the city,” said Mr. Smith, who moved to Butler in 2014. “I think we all know that none of these old steel towns, coal towns, are going to be the way that they once were back in the heyday.”
Art institutions also dot the landscape, ranging from the nonprofit Butler Art Center to The Maridon Museum, which houses a collection of Asian art dating back more than 4,000 years.
The Butler County Symphony Orchestra and the Butler Little Theatre add to the city’s cultural vibrancy.
“I just maybe thought all communities had what we have, to a degree, but not as much,” said Carole Fruehstorfer, 78, a Butler resident for more than 50 years. She volunteers as a docent at The Maridon, which was started by lifetime Butler resident Mary Hulton Phillips, who in 1944 married the grandson of Butler oil and natural gas baron T.W. Phillips.
The Maridon features nearly 800 pieces in its collection, including Asian ivory, jade and Meissen porcelain figures. Ms. Phillips gathered the objects throughout her life, which coincided with Butler’s economic rise and fall.
A rise and fall
The rise came in the early 1900s when railcar manufacturer Pullman-Standard and steel producer Armco began their plants in the area.
The fall arrived in the 1980s and 1990s, with Pullman-Standard closing its plant in February 1982 and AK Steel acquiring Armco in 1999, then downsizing the workforce.
When Pullman closed, what followed was the loss of thousands of jobs (including those in subsidiary businesses) and a jump in county unemployment to nearly 20%.
“Certainly by the ’80s you saw the younger generations not coming back to Butler,” said Pat Collins, the Butler County Historical Society executive director, who was born here in 1956. “They go to school, and they don’t come back. Your big and better employers aren’t here anymore. Why stay here if there’s nowhere to get a job?”
AK Steel maintained a presence with a 1,300-acre site in the bordering town of Lyndora, where most steelworkers and Pullman-Standard employees were based.
Kenny Bonus, a 31-year-old Butler city councilman, was born in Lyndora and remembers growing up and hearing people talk about Butler’s glory days.
“It almost seems like the people in the generation above mine, they saw the decline and it almost put their morale on the decline as well,” Mr. Bonus said. “[It] prevented them from seeing anything greater or better because they had known something great to begin with.”
While Butler’s downswing continued into the new century, southern Butler County experienced a boom.
Economic and residential growth spilled out from Allegheny County and concentrated around Cranberry, where attractions like the UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex and the headquarters of Westinghouse Electric contrasted with Butler’s struggles.
Modern, well-maintained residential areas predominate south of Butler, alongside new technology companies, like II-VI Incorporated in Saxonburg and Mine Safety Appliances in Cranberry.
Part of this came from a need to adapt following the decline of industry, according to Stan Kosciuszko, president of the Butler County Chamber of Commerce since 2002.
“Any economist will tell you, it’s better to have 20 baskets with a dozen eggs in each one, than one basket with 20 dozen eggs in it,” Mr. Kosciuszko said.
He said Butler County’s low unemployment rate, which now hovers around 3.4%, is a problem since jobs are going unfilled because of a lack of prospective workers.
Officials have been working to revitalize Butler’s downtown, hoping to attract businesses and their employees to the county seat.
Organizations like Butler Downtown, a nonprofit coalition of residents, business owners and other volunteers, have strived to beautify the area, attracting crowds to annual events such as the Italian Festival and the Bantam Jeep Heritage Festival (a nod to the American Bantam Car Co., which invented the Jeep prototype in Butler in 1940).
“From a perception standpoint, if you see a thriving Main Street, you assume a lot of different aspects,” Mr. Bonus said. “You assume the county and city are starting to thrive.”
One of Main Street’s staples is Cummings Coffee & Candy, the oldest family-run business in the city. It’s been in operation for more than 110 years, and has had the same Main Street location for more than a century.
Barry Cummings is the third generation of his family to own and operate the business.
After graduating from Robert Morris University in 1995, he joined his father, Thomas, in the shop. He recalled the struggles of 25 years ago, when empty storefronts lined Main Street.
“If people had an extra $10 to spend, it wasn’t going to be on chocolate or a soda fountain,” Mr. Cummings said.
An array of faded photos hangs near the ceiling of the shop, allowing customers and employees to reflect on the progression of the business through the years.
Despite being a throwback to Butler’s past, the shop is still part of the city’s wave of business adaptation. It has a second location inside Butler Memorial Hospital, showing a partnership between an established business and the city’s significant health care industry.
“I feel, as a business owner and someone who is plugged in on Main Street, that there’s a lot of positivity happening downtown,” Mr. Cummings said.
Retaining its citizens
One of the key goals in Butler’s current rebuilding process is encouraging the city’s young population to stay.
More than 6,000 students attend the Butler Area School District, which covers 11 municipalities in the county. About half of those students attend either Butler Intermediate High School or the Senior High, both located in the city.
District Superintendent Brian White doesn’t view it as his place to convince students to stay after graduating, but course offerings in his district, and at the community college, are tailored toward the region’s job openings.
Automation and robotics courses now are required at the eighth grade level in the district, but the arts still play a major role, as the district’s STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) focus has become STEAM (A for arts).
“It is stunning, because you wouldn't think of that necessarily when you hear the word Butler,” Mr. White said. “When you see the arts commitment by the students, the district, the parents, families, you can understand there’s an underlying foundational belief in the arts that’s driving a lot of it.”
Ashley Nassal is the art education director for the Butler Art Center. On a given night she can be found in the center’s gallery and workshop space, cheerfully critiquing sketches and watercolors painted by children.
She moved to Butler from Boston about six years ago, attracted by the area’s affordable housing and the advantage her bachelor’s degree gave her in the local job market, compared to Boston’s.
Ms. Nassal’s role at the center includes approving classes, hiring teachers and arranging for supplies, but also acting as a support system for children to express themselves in a positive environment that offsets some of the area’s social ills.
“There’s a huge epidemic of substance abuse,” Ms. Nassal said. “This is a healthy way to work stress and anxieties out.”
As in other Pennsylvania regions, opioids have been deadly in Butler County. Overdose deaths have declined, however, from 92 in 2017 to 46 in 2018.
Butler Police Chief Robert O’Neill, who took that position in November, said drug-related violence is low in the city despite the presence of narcotics.
A county drug task force operates in Butler, and Chief O’Neill cited mandatory foot patrols for officers and a change from unmarked to marked vehicles as ways narcotics trafficking has been addressed.
“We’re making progress,” Chief O’Neill said. “I wouldn’t say we have any problems fixed, but we’re making progress.”
Like Ms. Nassal, the historical society’s Ms. Collins believes art can spur further progress in Butler.
After visiting Pontiac, Ill., which has 18 murals painted by the Walldogs, a volunteer group of painters and muralists from around the world, Ms. Collins helped bring the group to Butler in 2016.
Among the 10 history-themed murals etched onto Butler’s buildings were those honoring American Revolutionary War Maj. Gen. Richard Butler, whose name became the city’s; the steel industry in Butler; and, of course, the Bantam Jeep. It was a merging of Butler’s past and present, in a way not overshadowing the city’s second act.
“Whether you think it’s good or bad, you have to have change to move on in life,” Ms. Collins said. “I don’t want Butler to be what it was when I was 10 years old. Things have to change. It has to evolve.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.