While Mars Area officials do the final tweaking of the district’s 2018-19 budget, parents and students pleaded with the school board Tuesday not to balance the budget by cutting band classes.
The board could vote next week on a preliminary budget that raises real estate taxes by 2.4 percent from 99 mills to 101.376 mills.
“I doubt that the final version of the budget will be exactly the same as the tentative budget,” said board president J. Dayle Ferguson. “We hope and plan to take action next week, but we have until June 30 to pass a final budget.”
The tentative budget calls for the addition of an elementary literacy intervention specialist and a guidance counselor. It also calls for not replacing some retiring teachers and eliminating extra music lessons in middle school. Band lessons in middle school include a full class, plus pull-out lessons for small groups of students.
Several students and parents spoke against the proposed cuts.
Jacob Smith, who was wearing a sweatshirt proclaiming that he is a 2018 Pennsylvania All-State Musician, said the pull-out lessons help students advance faster than just the weekly large-group rehearsal. “Removal of these lessons will prove to be a significant issue in the future,” he said.
Ruth O’Donnell, president of the marching band boosters, said participation in music programs has grown from 284 students in 2010 to 449 students now. In 2010, the staff to student ratio in band was 71:1. If another music position is eliminated, with the growing numbers, the ratio will be 224:1.
“Our program is growing in numbers and is proven to be successful,” she said. “This proposed cut was done without having conversations with the teachers, with the parents, with the students. These lessons at the middle school level are vital to the program so they can continue to develop the skills needed.”
She added that students get one or two years of lessons at the Centennial School, which houses fifth and sixth grades, but the teacher gives up her lunch and preparation periods in order to reach all interested students.
“For the past two years, I have sat at 16 (Pennsylvania Music Educators Association) concerts. At those concerts, I always sat there very proud of the programs we had here at Mars. Now I am questioning that,” she said.
District officials have always said that the band boosters were organized, easy to work with and supportive, Ms. O’Donnell said. “One thing we cannot do is take this decision quietly. “I ask you, over the next week, that you sit down with the administrators and you look at those numbers again.”
Lisa Kumpfmiller said the small group lessons teach students who play the same instrument how to play together. “It makes us competitive,” she said, adding that Mars Area won the PMEA AAA championship against “districts that put lots of money into their music program, and we beat them.”
Ninth-grader Libby Roda said “it will just break my heart” if the music program is cut. “I want to make it really clear to you right now that the music program has helped me more than any teacher has or will,” she said.
“I stand before you as a living and breathing example of how the music program literally saves lives,” said Mia Giglietti, adding that, before she discovered marching band, “I was so incredibly lost and did not know what I wanted to do. … When we won championships in October, I felt a sense of accomplishment that I never felt before. To watch other kids not be able to have that same experience is heartbreaking.”
Board member Christine Valenta noted that the district has seven music teachers. Although she is passionate about music, it is more important to add a reading specialist for general education students who are not reading at grade level, she said.
“We need to consider the needs of all 3,400 students in the district,” she said. “There are needs and there are wants. There is a need to make sure that these students are reading at the level they are participating in. They need to be reading at grade level.”
Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.