Butler County’s chief prosecutor said Thursday he will seek the death penalty for a man accused of raping and killing his girlfriend’s four-year-old son.
Keith Lambing
District Attorney Rich Goldinger confirmed that the “paperwork is being prepared” to officially notify the court that the county will seek the ultimate penalty for 20-year-old Keith Jordan Lambing.
That confirmation came after Mr. Lambing was held for court Thursday on several felony charges stemming from the March 21 death of Bentley Miller, who bled out after being sodomized, according to medical testimony given at his preliminary hearing before District Judge Kevin O’Donnell of Butler Township.
Mr. Goldinger described the killing as horrific and said he believes the “special circumstances” in the case warrant the death penalty. In Pennsylvania, only cases involving aggravated circumstances — such as the killing of a child — can be tried as death penalty cases.
Mr. Lambing, whose address is listed in court paperwork as being in the North Hills, was raised in Butler County. He has resided in Slippery Rock and Butler.
Read More
He remained silent, his face impassive, as evidence against him was presented Thursday. A woman who declined to identify herself but who was said to be his grandmother cried silently throughout the hearing.
Todd Luckasevic, a forensic pathologist from Bridgeville, testified to grueling injuries Bentley received and to the precise cause of his death: exsanguination due to perforation and laceration of his rectum, anus, and abdominal wall. He said the injuries were caused by sodomy, committed with an object or a body part — he said it was not possible to tell from the autopsy.
Dr. Luckasevic said the injuries and resulting blood loss were so severe the child would have been unconscious within minutes. He also testified that Bentley’s body was covered with bruises and a serious burn to his hand. Some of the bruises, located on the front of his torso, were in the shape of hands, as though the child had been held tightly from behind.
Butler County Detective Thomas Vensel described the scene at Butler Memorial Hospital where the little boy was pronounced dead the morning of March 21, less than an hour after Mr. Lambing’s mother — Kristen Herold, 43, of Butler— made a frantic call to Butler 911 saying Bentley was unconscious in her car. She had just picked him up from the Super 8 Motel in Butler Township, where he had been under the care of her son, to transport him to his father’s house, according to court documents and testimony.
The detective said he had verified that the child’s mother, Mackenzie Peters, had left the motel at about 6:30 a.m., the detective said. The only other person at the motel besides Mr. Lambing was a four-month-old boy, the son of Mr. Lambing and Ms. Peters. The two adults and two children had been living at the motel for a few weeks, according to authorities.
Under cross examination by defense attorney Frank Walker of Pittsburgh, who has been privately retained by Mr. Lambing’s family, the detective acknowledged that the investigation is ongoing and that the results of certain forensic tests have not yet been received.
In the end, District Judge O’Donnell held Mr. Lambing on counts of criminal homicide, involuntary deviate sexual intercourse with a child with serious bodily injury; rape of a child; rape of a child with serious bodily injury; aggravated indecent assault of a child; aggravated assault; endangering the welfare of children; and reckless endangerment. Mr. Walker argued only that the rape counts should not be held.
Immediately following the conclusion of the first case, a second preliminary hearing was held — this one before District Judge B.T. Fullerton of Butler. Mr. Lambing is charged with planning an escape from the Butler County Prison where he has been held since he was taken into custody by authorities March 24 on a warrant. He was charged three days later with criminal homicide. He was defended by Butler County Public Defender Joseph Smith.
Jeffrey Kengerski, a corrections officer at the county prison, told the court that on March 27 he overheard Mr. Lambing on the phone with his grandmother, saying he would show her something during the visit the next day. He said he alerted his supervisors.
The next morning, before the visit, Mr. Lambing was searched. In his pocket was a note written in large letters that described what Mr. Kengerski described as an “escape plan.”
Butler County Detective Timothy Fennell said that, on March 28, he received from the prison that note and that it had information indicating that a vehicle used to transport of prisoners often is unlocked. The note also referenced his mother and that she “takes the blame for it all.”
During arguments by his defense attorney, Mr. Smith described the supposed escape plan as “a ridiculous thought…He indulged in a fantasy. This is a flight of fancy.” He said prosecutors were piling on.
Assistant District Attorney Terri Schultz said Mr. Lambing did more than just fantasize about escaping: he wrote a plan; he talked about it to his grandmother; and he had it in his pocket the morning of the scheduled visit. District Judge Fullerton held the case for court.
Mr. Lambing remains in the county lockup without bail.
After the hearings, Mr. Walker said in an interview he believes his client is being presumed guilty. “There are issues with this case. They don’t even have DNA evidence back,” he said.
Asked whether his client professes his innocence, he declined to say. The attorney confirmed he has been retained by the family privately but that it is uncertain whether he will continue to represent Mr. Lambing. He said he is qualified to represent clients in a death penalty case.
Meanwhile, Mr. Lambing’s mother, Ms. Herold, was held for court March 29 on charges of helping her son evade police. They were found by police on March 22 at an abandoned home in Butler. She was charged March 24 with hindering apprehension and endangering the welfare of a child and is in jail, unable to post bond.
Bentley’s mother, Ms. Peters, was charged March 30 with endangering the welfare of a child for not seeking treatment of a blistering burn Bentley had sustained prior to his death. She is to face a preliminary hearings May 11.
Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or at 724-772-9180.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.