Juliet Evancho and Elissa Ridenour have been students in the Pine-Richland School District since they were in kindergarten.

Both have undergone a gender transformation from male — the sex they were assigned at birth — to female and said they had always felt relatively safe and supported in their schools.

But that changed last month after the school board passed a resolution reversing a longstanding district policy that had allowed students to use restrooms in accordance with their gender identities.

“We kind of felt that we were walking on glass beforehand, and with the support of our families and our friends they kind of put down that little blanket for us to walk on in safety,” Ms. Evancho said at a news conference Thursday. “Now it feels like that’s going to be ripped from under us, and we’re again treading very lightly because we’re afraid of getting hurt.”

Advertise with us

The school board Sept. 12 passed a resolution instructing students to use restrooms in accordance with the gender they were assigned on their birth certificate, a unisex bathroom or the private bathroom in the nurse’s office. The resolution spurred Lambda Legal, a national LGBT advocacy organization, and the law firm Kline and Specter to file a lawsuit Thursday in federal court in Pittsburgh on behalf of Ms. Evancho, Ms. Ridenour and a third student identified only as A.S. because he is a minor.

The suit against the district, superintendent Brian R. Miller and high school principal Nancy Bowman seeks a declaratory judgment, preliminary and permanent injunctions against the policy, and damages resulting from “discriminatory actions.”

Ms. Ridenour said felt she was a girl since she was a young child. When she was about 13, she began undertaking gender transition under the care of therapists and doctors, and by age 14 she was living as a girl.

She said that during her time at Pine-Richland High School she was known as a girl, referred to by female pronouns, and had access to the girls’ bathroom. She said she felt accepted until the resolution was passed.

“I sort of had a clear picture of who my allies were, and now I’m sort of wondering,” Ms. Ridenour said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Evancho shared a similar experience, feeling since she was a young child that she was a girl.

She began accepting her female gender identity around 2010, the same time that her sister, Jackie Evancho, was runner-up on the NBC-TV’s “America’s Got Talent.” Her sister’s singing fame made things more difficult for Ms. Evancho, who worried about how others would perceive her and her family as they garnered attention from the media.

Nevertheless, with support from her family, she eventually began living as a girl and felt that she was accepted at the high school.

The new policy has altered her feeling of acceptance, kept her away from using school bathrooms at all in the past few weeks, and even made her consider leaving school.

“At one point I thought I was going to leave the school until my faith in at least the student body had been restored when I was nominated homecoming queen,” she said.