A major issue in the case of the teen accused in the 2014 knife attack at Franklin Regional High School was resolved Monday when a judge decided he should be tried as an adult.
Alex Hribal, 18, who faces years in prison if convicted, could go to trial as early as July. He was 16 years old when police said he cut or stabbed 20 students and a security guard at the Murrysville school on April 9, 2014. He remains charged as an adult with 21 counts each of attempted homicide and aggravated assault.
“Simply put,” Common Pleas Judge Christopher A. Feliciani wrote in a decision Monday, “the court finds that the risk of the defendant’s relapse, potential for re-offending in a similar manner, now, or upon his release at age 21, and many unknown and unpredictable psychological/psychiatric factors, to outweigh the likelihood that the defendant’s re-entry into our community would be safe and of no concern to the community.”
Defense attorney Patrick Thomassey said he plans to file an interlocutory appeal to the state Superior Court, which would allow the defense team to take the matter to that appellate court before trial. Judge Feliciani could deny that request, however.
“I’m very disappointed, I really am. ... They medicate them and warehouse them. That’s what they do,” Mr. Thomassey said of adult prisons. “That’s why I thought it was so important to try to get him into the juvenile system.”
Mr. Thomassey filed the motion to move the case to juvenile court in March 2015, arguing that Mr. Hribal would get better treatment in that system. Injured students, mental health specialists for the prosecution and defense, and school personnel who intervened during the attack testified at hearings in June, October and November.
Read More
Joan Mellon, a Franklin Regional assistant principal credited with taking the twin kitchen knives from Mr. Hribal’s hands, testified that she cannot pick up a knife without recalling the incident.
Judge Feliciani in his order noted the “level of sophistication” in Mr. Hribal’s alleged actions, including his rambling manifesto in which he revealed admiration for the perpetrators of the Columbine High School massacre and included detailed plans to carry out a similar attack.
The judge sided with prosecution psychiatrist Bruce Wright, who testified that he couldn’t say whether Mr. Hribal was amenable to treatment or if he could be rehabilitated in the juvenile system. He further noted the “tremendous risk of relapse” with such a severe illness. The judge found defense psychiatrist Christine Martone’s opinion — including that Mr. Hribal would get the best treatment in the juvenile system — was “premised upon too much speculation and conditional analysis.”
Mr. Hribal has been in custody since the attack, first at the Westmoreland County juvenile detention center, then at the county jail, where he was moved when he turned 18 last October. If found responsible for the crimes in juvenile court, he would have been released from custody at 21.
Westmoreland County District Attorney John Peck said victims, their families and community members roundly believe that the alleged crimes did not warrant a sentence in the juvenile system.
“We think that the judge made a very thorough and complete analysis, and his decision is certainly justified by the evidence that was presented.”
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-363-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.