A federal judge this week rejected former state Sen. Jane Orie’s request for a new corruption trial.

Orie, convicted in 2012, had filed a lengthy habeas petition in September that raised many of the same arguments that the state court system had denied, including her claim that the prosecution violated her protections against double jeopardy and was driven by “personal animus” by District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Robert Mitchell ruled on Thursday that those claims and five others have no merit because none prove any violation of federal law.

On the double jeopardy issue, Orie had argued she was tried twice for the same offenses.

Advertise with us

But her first trial ended in a mistrial because her defense introduced forged documents, Judge Mitchell said.

The double jeopardy rule would prevent a retrial in the case of misconduct by prosecutors or the judge, but not by her own defense.

Judge Mitchell said her argument fails because “the impropriety is directly attributable to her.”

In regard to the animus claim, Orie had said the county trial judge, Jeffrey A. Manning, should have appointed a special prosecutor because the Zappala family has feuded with hers.

She has long argued that the Zappalas have opposed her because of their positions in the gambling industry while she was the “leading gambling reformer” in the Legislature.

Advertise with us

In ruling against her, Judge Manning had written in 2012 that the claim of a political feud driving the prosecution “was a red herring raised by the defense that had no basis in fact.”

Judge Mitchell said Orie raised nothing in her petition to counter that opinion.

Orie, a Republican from McCandless, was convicted in 2012 on charges of conspiracy, diversion of services and conflict of interest in using her staff to run her political campaigns. She served about 20 months in prison on her 2½- to 10-year sentence and remains on parole.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.