A federal court jury is expected to begin deliberating this morning over whether Millvale police Officer Nicole Murphy was justified in shocking a drunk and handcuffed suspect with her Taser two years ago.

The defense rested Tuesday without her taking the stand.

Instead, the jury heard from a paid defense witness, Pittsburgh police use-of-force expert Robert Swartzwelder, who said her use of the weapon on Thomas Smith was “reasonable” considering the circumstances, some of which were captured on video.

Officer Swartzwelder said Officer Murphy had to take action to prevent Mr. Smith from hurting himself as he repeatedly smacked his head against a cubicle divider at the station while sitting handcuffed on the floor.

Advertise with us

He also criticized her partner and the key government witness, former officer Casey Bonincontro, for sitting in a chair while recording Mr. Smith on his cell phone and laughing at his antics, leaving the job of pulling Mr. Smith away from the divider to two paramedics.

“Police have to intervene,” Officer Swartzwelder said.

Officer Murphy is charged with violating Mr. Smith’s civil rights by zapping him three times, twice with the weapon on drive-stun and once on probe-stun, in which probes penetrated the skin of his back to deliver an incapacitating shock.

She and her lawyer, Robert Stewart, argue that she had to stop him from injuring himself and also to keep him from attacking her and Officer Bonincontro. In her reports of the incident, she said Mr. Smith kicked her and spat on Officer Bonincontro, although Officer Bonincontro said Mr. Smith did neither.

In its closing argument, the government said Officer Murphy had no reason to shock Mr. Smith other than her irritation at him because he was mouthing off at the officers in a drunken stupor while she was trying to do paperwork.

Advertise with us

At one point, according to testimony, she said she didn’t want to take “this retard” to Western Psychiatric Institute, as Officer Bonincontro suggested, and wanted instead to take him to jail. Cindy Chung, a Justice Department lawyer, said the officer was working at her desk when she “just snaps” at his taunts.

“The reason she tased him is that she simply got sick of him,” she said.

Then she wrote in her reports that he kicked her and was growing increasingly violent to justify her use of force, Ms. Chung said.

But Mr. Stewart told the jury that Mr. Smith's behavior was “escalating” and that she had to do something because her “bump-on-a-log partner” was doing nothing except recording the episode “for posterity.”

He also suggested that the case against his client was motivated by revenge. He said Officer Bonincontro gave the cell phone video to another officer who had been fired and against whom Officer Murphy was a witness in the termination proceedings. The video was later leaked to the media.

Advertise with us

“This was payback” to get Officer Murphy, said Mr. Stewart said.

If Officer Murphy is convicted, she can never again work as a police officer.