A federal court jury today will begin hearing the case of a Millvale police officer charged with violating a handcuffed man’s civil rights by repeatedly zapping him with her stun gun during an incident that a fellow officer recorded on a cell phone.
Officer Nicole Murphy, 30, doesn’t deny she used the weapon on Thomas Smith in September 2012 after his arrest for public drunkenness, but she and her lawyer, Robert Stewart, say she did it to keep him from hurting himself as he began smacking his head against the leg of a desk at the police station, where he was sitting handcuffed on the floor.
Mr. Stewart has declined to comment as the case goes to trial, but after a court appearance for his client this summer he said she had no choice but to zap Mr. Smith because he was “out of control.” In court papers, Mr. Stewart has also indicated that Officer Murphy used the weapon on Mr. Smith because she feared he was going to attack a fellow officer, Casey Bonincontro, whose cell phone video of the incident is central to the case.
The U.S. attorney’s office, however, says Officer Murphy violated Mr. Smith’s civil rights and abused her power as an officer.
The incident came to light in 2013, when someone sent the video to the media. The FBI investigated, and a grand jury indicted Officer Murphy in June, charging her with one count of “deprivation of rights under color of law.”
In the video, Mr. Smith is seen sitting shirtless on the floor, plainly drunk, and starts banging his head against the desk leg. Officer Murphy then draws her stun gun and zaps him.
Both sides have sparred over how much the jury will hear about the character and conduct of Officer Murphy and Officer Bonincontro, the key government witness, and the scope of a report that defense witness Robert Swartzwelder, a Pittsburgh police officer and expert on use of force, made.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Carolyn Bloch and Cindy Chung, a lawyer with the Justice Department’s civil rights division, have asked the judge, Arthur Schwab, to let them attack Officer Murphy's character if she takes the stand.
If Mr. Stewart is allowed to introduce evidence of her various awards and commendations, they want to question her about a 2011 drunken-driving arrest expunged from her record after she completed a first-time offender program and her “fraternization” with a man known to have a drug-related criminal record.
Mr. Stewart objected, saying the officer’s past has nothing to do with the incident and shouldn’t be allowed.
The judge ruled that the government may not introduce the DUI and the fraternization accusation but that it could be raised on cross-examination.
A similar debate arose last week over Officer Bonincontro’s character and conduct. To discredit the officer as a witness, Mr. Stewart wanted to be able to introduce personnel files from Millvale and two other departments to show a pattern of job rule violations. The files purportedly indicate that Officer Bonincontro missed court dates and responded too slowly to a call.
The government, however, said the files aren’t relevant because they don’t relate to truthfulness as a witness to the incident.
The judge ruled Friday that the files cannot be introduced but left the door open for Mr. Stewart to use portions of them if they “become relevant during trial.”
The final issue is a use-of-force report and testimony by Officer Swartzwelder. His report isn’t public but presumably concludes that Officer Murphy was justified in using the stun gun.
The government asked the judge to bar him from making any such legal conclusions, instead limiting his testimony to hypothetical situationsand use-of-force policy in general.
Judge Schwab on Friday denied the government’s motion, saying any deficiencies in the Swartzwelder report can be handled during the trial.
Officer Murphy is on unpaid leave pending the outcome of the case.
Millvale paid $37,500 to settle Mr. Smith’s related lawsuit against her and the borough.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.