The new Butler County Board of Commissioners will feature familiar faces in January -- an incumbent board chairman, a man who had served a four-year term in the 1990s, and a local gadfly who has attended as many public meetings as his colleagues on the board.

The question now is how the three will get along when they're seated together.

The unofficial winners Tuesday were board Chairman Dale Pinkerton, a Republican who is finishing his first four-year term; his running mate and fellow Republican Bill McCarrier, a commissioner from 1996 to 1999; and Democrat Jim Eckstein, a local contractor who has attended almost every regular public meeting of the board since he lost his bid for election four years ago.

Mr. Eckstein has cultivated a reputation as an "outsider" for his diatribes against Mr. Pinkerton, Democrat Jim Lokhaiser, who was defeated in the primary, and Republican Jim Kennedy, who retired a few months ago after many years in office.

Advertise with us

In relationship to Mr. Pinkerton, Mr. Eckstein's derisive comments have ranged in topic from the board chairman's flamboyant suit coats to accusations of trying to influence an independent advisory committee to recommend the shutdown of the county-owned nursing home.

Mr. Eckstein did not return calls seeking comment following the election. But, in a pre-election interview, when asked how he would work with Mr. Pinkerton should they both be elected, Mr. Eckstein responded: "Ask him how he'll work with me."

Mr. Pinkerton said he has considered his personal strong suit the ability to work with others. "Hopefully, I'll be able to continue to do that," he said.

Mr. McCarrier said the relationship with Mr. Eckstein will depend on him. "That's up to Jim. If he wants to work as part of a team, then we'll have a team."

The Tuesday night vote counting was a nail-biter, with each of four candidates garnering votes at similar paces. In the end, the top vote-getters were Mr. McCarrier, Mr. Pinkerton and Mr. Eckstein.

Advertise with us

Defeated by fewer than 500 votes was Democratic newcomer Jerry Johnston, who said after the balloting that he was "very disappointed." He didn't close the door to a challenge of the vote tally but said he would wait and see how things develop.

"I'm not really sure of all the options," Mr. Johnston said. Unofficial vote totals, which do not include absentee ballots, showed him less than 1 percentage point behind Mr. Eckstein.

Mr. Pinkerton, of Butler, said his goal for the coming four-year term is to keep doing what he's been doing.

"Butler County is doing well," he said, noting that, during his tenure, the county was ranked in a recent federal study as the sixth-biggest job growth market in the United States. Unemployment rates are consistently lower than state and national averages, as well.

Mr. McCarrier, of Butler Township, echoed those remarks, noting that his hope is to keep Butler "moving forward in the same direction" in which it's headed.

Advertise with us

The field of four contenders was reduced from nine in the spring primary election. The retirement of Mr. Kennedy sparked interest.

Mr. Eckstein, also of Butler Township, is a residential contractor who has an associate's degree in drafting. His campaign slogan was "Not just a change, but a difference." He maintains that the county's debt is uncontrolled and salaries are out of whack with the private sector.

Mr. McCarrier, a retired businessman, sits on the boards of the Community Development Corporation, chamber of commerce, community college, fire chiefs association, and Salvation Army. He owned Interstate Pipe and Supply Co. until recently, selling the business to his children.

Mr. Johnston, who also is from Butler Township, is a youth care worker at Adelphoi Village. He had worked for 23 years as an advertising and public affairs manager for North Pittsburgh Telephone Co. until he accepted an early retirement when the company was sold in 2007 to Consolidated Communications.

Mr. Pinkerton is a retired regional manager for Goodyear and was a licensed funeral director.