In a nail-biting contest Tuesday for three seats on the Butler County board of commissioners, voters issued an invitation to Chairman Dale Pinkerton but also welcomed aboard a political newcomer who has made a practice of public diatribe against the incumbent the past four years.

Based on preliminary totals that showed the four-man race to be close from start to finish, Democrat Jim Eckstein, a local contractor who ran unsuccessfully four years ago, will be seated in January as will Mr. Pinkerton's running mate, fellow Republican Bill McCarrier, a local entrepreneur who serves on the county's economic development agency board of directors.

It appears that Democratic contender and political newcomer Jerry Johnston was defeated by a hair. The two top vote-getters in the "vote for three" contest were Mr. McCarrier and Mr. Pinkerton, respectively. The spread between Mr. Eckstein and Mr. Johnston was minimal.

"I'm very pleased that I've been given another chance to continue doing what I've been doing to make Butler County the success that it is," said Mr. Pinkerton.

Advertise with us

His remarks were echoed by Mr. McCarrier: "I'm humbled and I'm honored. I'm looking forward to keeping Butler County on the roll we've been on."

Mr. Eckstein could not be reached for comment.

Mr. Johnston said he was "disappointed but proud of the clean campaign we ran."

The field of four contenders was reduced from nine in the spring primary election. The retirement of longtime former commissioner Jim Kennedy sparked interest in the race for three open seats of four-year terms. Sitting Commissioner Jim Lokhaiser was defeated in the primary.

Mr. Pinkerton, of Butler City, promised continued success for Butler County if he secured a second four-year term.

Advertise with us

During his tenure, the county was ranked in a recent federal study as the sixth biggest job growth market in the United States.

Unemployment rates are consistently lower than state and national averages, as well.

Mr. Eckstein, of Butler Township, a residential contractor who has an associate degree in drafting, has fashioned himself a regular nay-sayer at virtually every public meeting of the board since he lost his bid for election four years ago. His slogan is "Not just a change, but a difference."

He says the county's debt is uncontrolled and salaries are out of whack with the private sector.

Mr. McCarrier, of Butler Township, who ran a joint campaign with Mr. Pinkerton, served as county commissioner from 1996 to 1999. He believes the county is moving in the right direction and that he has the skills to keep it on track. He sits on the boards of the Community Development Corp., chamber of commerce, community college, fire chiefs association and Salvation Army.

He also owned Interstate Pipe and Supply Co. until recently selling the business to his children.