The Pennsylvania Superior Court this morning issued an opinion agreeing that state Sen. Jane Orie's appeal stemming from the mistrial of her criminal case is frivolous.

In a 22-page opinion, a three-judge panel agreed with Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning that declaring a mistrial was required after the discovery of doctored documents during her trial for allegedlhy misusing her legislative resources to do campaign work.

The mistrial was declared on March 3, after the jury started deliberating.

"[When] given the opportunity, [Ms. Orie] suggested no viable alternatives to a mistrial," the appeals court wrote. Continuing, it said, "[The] record supports the court's determination that [Ms. Orie] was responsible for the mistrial, and she cannot place liability for the mistrial on either the court or the commonwealth."

Advertise with us

The Superior Court concluded that the defense held the forged documents "for months, until the latest possible moment at trial," before providing them to the prosecution, and that Ms. Orie authenticated the evidence at trial "in a manner that was indeed critical to her defense."

Ms. Orie's attorney, William Costopoulos, appealed Judge Manning's decision, claiming that a retrial on the charges would constitute a double jeopardy violation.

The district attorney's office this week charged Ms. Orie in connection with the documents.

More details in tomorrow's Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.