A controversial race for district judge in Shaler veered away from the criminal last week when a judge dismissed a charge against one of the candidates.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski last week tossed out a single harassment charge against Daniel Hargrove, 48.

County police had accused Mr. Hargrove of making a harassing phone call against one of his political opponents, Michael Heinl.

Both men were running against incumbent Judge Robert Dzvonick, who won nomination on both party ballots in May.

Advertise with us

Mr. Heinl, a former Shaler police officer, reported to Shaler police that he received a harassing phone call from a blocked number around 11:51 p.m. on April 12. Mr. Heinl said he recognized the voice as Mr. Hargrove.

County police investigated the case at the request of Shaler police. It traced the blocked number to Mr. Hargrove's cell phone.

Mr. Hargrove said the cell phone was for campaign use and not usually in his possession.

Judge Borkowski ruled that the incident among otherwise upstanding, professional men stemmed from an intense political climate and should be put behind them. He told them that the situation did not merit using the resources of the criminal justice system.