In 2011's turbulent political environment, voters in Etna, Millvale, Reserve, and Shaler face the choice of re-electing incumbent Robert Dzvonick to another six-year term, or replacing him with one of three challengers seeking to win the district judge seat in the area.

Typically low-visibility affairs, elections for these local judicial positions often feature many candidates for an open seat. Once elected, the new incumbent generally manages to hold the seat for many years with little or no opposition.

Such is not the case here. Mr. Dzvonick's challengers in the upcoming May 17 primary are Daniel Hargrove, Michael Heinl, and Adam Schuster. All but Mr. Schuster are on both the Democratic and Republican ballots. According to the League of Women Voters, Mr. Schuster will appear only on the Democratic side.

Mr. Dzvonick ran unopposed in 2005, according to the Allegheny County elections office. The county's oldest election information online shows he won both party nominations in the 1999 primaries, against Hal English. Mr. Dzvonick has no known website or campaign phone number for the 2011 elections. Repeated attempts to reach the judge at his office for comment on the election were unsuccessful.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dzvonick most recently made the news last week when a man who had appeared in his courtroom the morning of April 21 shot himself to death on the North Side shortly after. The individual failed to turn over his guns to Pittsburgh police as required by a protection from abuse order. Mr. Dzvonick and the Allegheny County district attorney's office had expected the man to return that afternoon with proof of turning in the weapons.

Challenger Dan Hargrove is an attorney born and raised in Shaler. He graduated from La Roche College and later Duquesne University Law School. He served in the county district attorney's office in the late 1980s. According to his campaign website, Mr. Hargrove since has practiced several types of law, including civil, criminal, family, juvenileand bankruptcy.

While district judges are not required to have a law degree, Mr. Hargrove emphasizes his legal career as one of his main qualifications for the job. His website says he "has developed a keen knowledge of our laws, and how they are applied and utilized both in and out of the courtroom."

Last Thursday, Mr. Hargrove appeared before Judge Jeffrey Manning in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court seeking approval of a petition to file a private criminal complaint against a man he claimed had removed his campaign signs and intimidated him, allegedly on behalf of a competitor in the race.

Mr. Hargrove said when he complained to Shaler police and later to the county district attorney's office, he was told there was insufficient evidence to press charges.

Advertise with us

Mr. Hargrove asked the judge to approve theft and terroristic threat charges against the man, who was not named in court.

Judge Manning ordered a representative of the district attorney's office to investigate Mr. Hargrove's complaint and report on the findings. The judge said another hearing would be scheduled after he received the report.

A third candidate, Mike Heinl, resigned from the Shaler police force to announce his campaign for the district judge post in February. That ended a 20-year stint on the force for Mr. Heinl, who spent the first nine years there as a patrol officer. Since then he has served as a juvenile detective. He also has served on various drug task forces and spoken on law enforcement topics to students in Shaler Area schools. Mr. Heinl, of Shaler, graduated from Indiana University of Pennsylvania with a bachelor's degree in criminology in 1991.

He cites his willingness to give up a secure job on the police force as evidence he will put the people first.

"Not many politicians can show that kind of commitment when it comes to sacrificing their paycheck in order to help their constituents," Mr. Heinl said on his website. The site also describes Mr. Heinl as having conservative political views.

Advertise with us

Candidate Adam Schuster is 19 years old. His campaign's Facebook site says he is running for "district justice," a title eliminated during statewide judicial reforms that took effect in 2005, when the official title became magisterial district judge, or district judge in popular usage.

A 2010 graduate of Shaler Area High School, Mr. Schuster points to his lack of law enforcement background as a plus. "I am not a member of law enforcement so my time in office would be entirely neutral," he writes on the site. He plans to graduate from Duquesne University in 2014. He has lived in Shaler for 11 years.