A federal appellate court has reinstated part of a lawsuit in which a Franklin Park couple sued Google over online photos of their home because they said it was an invasion of privacy.
The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday overturned part of a February 2009 decision by U.S. Magistrate Judge Amy Reynolds Hay to dismiss the case.
The suit, originally brought in Allegheny County in 2008 and later removed to federal court in Pittsburgh, was believed to be the first of its kind in the U.S. and something of a test case for online privacy issues.
Aaron and Christine Boring said Google's images of their home on its "Street View" mapping tool violated their privacy, devalued their property and caused them mental suffering.
In granting Google's request for dismissal last year, Judge Hay said the couple didn't provide evidence that the images caused them any real harm.
In her ruling, she said the couple could not prove their privacy claims because they couldn't show that "Google's conduct was highly offensive to a person of ordinary sensibilities," the legal standard in such cases.
The 3rd Circuit upheld her ruling on all counts except one in which the couple said Google trespassed on their property to get the pictures. Judge Hay dismissed the trespass count based on the fact that the couple did not state a damage claim. The appellate judges said that was a mistake.
"Here, the Borings have alleged that Google entered upon their property without permission. If proven, that is a trespass, pure and simple," the judges wrote.
The case will be returned to U.S. District Court on the trespass allegation.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.