Bob Donaldson
The proposed Deer Creek Crossing development would put a shopping center, office and hotel complex along Pennsylvania Route 910 near Rich Hill Road in Harmar Township.
Click photo for larger image.
Fishing Notebook:
Dutch Fork Lake spillway notch to improve safety
Sprawl is a huge issue in Pennsylvania where, despite declining population, we are consuming natural habitat almost three times faster than we are conserving it, according to the U.S. Agriculture Department, which estimates the loss at 385 acres a day.
About 260 acres near Deer Creek may be headed for the same fate, as Allegheny County council prepares to vote on tax increment financing for a retail/hotel/office complex, Deer Creek Crossing, in Harmar Township. The county economic development office unveiled its TIF plan at a public hearing Jan. 5, at which those who oppose government subsidies for the project made impassioned pleas against it, while supporters hoisted placards and testified in praise of the planned mall. Fewer than half of county council's 15 members were present, though council will decide the matter, perhaps as early as next month.
"Every plant and community needs new cells to stay alive. I look at this project, Deer Creek Crossing, as a new cell for the growth of Allegheny County," Harmar supervisor Don Muse told council.
"My name is Ken Lloyd, I live in Springdale, I'm not a candidate for any office and I happen to like sprawl ..." said another resident to laughter and applause from fellow supporters.
Trout Unlimited and Tri County Trout Club have decried Deer Creek Crossing in the eight years it has been in contention. Former Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited president Ken Undercoffer has followed the situation from his home in central Pennsylvania.
"Urban trout streams are precious natural resources," he said. "There are so few of them, yet there are so many other places to build malls."
Deer Creek supports 27 species of fish, according to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, including walleye, sauger and smallmouth bass. The Fish and Boat Commission stocks trout in the delayed harvest section, a hot spot from the opening day of trout season, on. In addition, Deer Creek's wetlands -- which will be destroyed by the project -- were described in a 1994 natural heritage inventory by the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy as among the best examples of flood plain forest and marshland in terms of location and biodiversity. The developer will build new wetlands, but experts say that created wetlands seldom measure up to the originals, which have formed over hundreds of thousands of years.
"Animals don't always go to the created wetlands, so you can wind up with a monoculture, with 50 species instead of 200," said U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologist Rick McCoy from his office in State College. "You don't always wind up with the plants you intended, either. It upsets the entire watershed."
Heather Sage, outreach coordinator of PennFuture, a public interest group that has led the fight against Deer Creek Crossing, testified to the irony of using public money intended to eradicate blight "to destroy green space, induce sprawl and create another kind of blight." Four years ago, PennFuture sued, seeking to get the TIF for Deer Creek Crossing thrown out. The developer altered his design and reapplied. Another lawsuit is not out of the question, PennFuture attorney Jody Rosenberg said, especially since the county failed to make the TIF plan and a less than rosy economic impact report available to the public in a timely manner.
PennFuture is demanding that council hold another hearing, and only after it has given people time to read and analyze county projections.
Under the plan, 80 percent of new property tax revenue from Deer Creek Crossing would be diverted from the county, Harmar and the Allegheny Valley School District for 20 years to help cover the cost of publicly owned infrastructure associated with the $124 million project. The TIF bond would gross $30.7 million and net $22.5 million for public improvements.
"To destroy wetlands to build a shopping center with public assistance, what does this say about our values?" asked Sharon Pillar of the Pittsburgh Interfaith Impact Network in her testimony. "[County chief executive] Dan Onorato promised PIN he would halt the use of TIF for green spaces. So did county council. They need to stop prostituting natural resources to developers."
The developer, Stephen Kozlik of the Texas based Woodmont Company, testified to concessions his company is planning to make. Besides wetlands construction, he has downsized the site and is setting it back from the stream by 240 feet instead of 100 feet, as originally planned. He said he will install bio-filtration systems to manage storm water run-off and plant 53,000 trees and shrubs.
Still, said Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson from his office in Somerset, "there will be impacts from the development. There are always impacts. The best you can hope for is they're minimal. The developer may have made changes to the original plan but that isn't enough to avoid impacts."
Aside from environmental concerns, opponents called Deer Creek Crossing a poor financial risk in an area that is losing population. The new shops will take people away from other businesses, creating hardship in neighboring communities, said Jean Zang, another representative of the Pittsburgh Interfaith Impact Network. "The only one who stands to profit is the developer and he won't be spending his profits in our community or even our state."
Few of those who testified were aware of the county's report raising serious concerns about economic impact. It indicated that 63 percent of Deer Creek Crossing's revenues would most likely come at the expense of retailers in nearby malls, such as the Waterworks in Fox Chapel.
"It goes without saying that other malls and independent businesses will be displaced," said Philip LaMay, a county business development specialist. "If a business closes at the Waterworks, the question becomes, who fills that gap?"
County council's business development committee will meet to discuss Deer Creek Crossing at 5 p.m. Thursday in conference room No. 1, room 119, at the Allegheny County Courthouse. The public can attend.
For more information, visit www.county.allegheny.pa.us/agenda/jan25/250120.pdf
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.