David R. Thomas, the star speaker at today's Pittsburgh City Council meeting on domestic abuse and policing, believes in thorough investigations, consistent discipline and a safety-first approach when officers are accused of violence against family members.

He'll take that message to council members and police administrators in a city where investigations and discipline are shrouded and officers subject to protection-from-abuse orders are not always barred from carrying guns.

The issue of police domestic abuse came to the fore in June, when three out of four officers promoted at the same time were found to have faced allegations or investigations in the past.

At least 34 city police officers currently on the job have been accused of stalking, threatening, and verbally or physically abusing their spouses, significant others, former domestic partners or a family member.

Advertise with us

The allegations against the officers were discovered by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in a search of civil court records and are contained in petitions for protection-from-abuse orders, or PFAs. The oldest date to 1995; the newest are from this year. Most have expired.

Police Chief Nathan E. Harper, who has the ultimate discretion to take action against accused officers, refused to detail the bureau's handling of such matters or to be interviewed for this story. Deputy Chief Paul Donaldson deferred comment until after today's meeting.

James J. Malloy, president of the Fraternal Order of Police, and Bryan Campbell, the union's lawyer, acknowledged that there are probably some police officers who have been involved in domestics with their partners.

"At one time that was as common as dirt," said Mr. Malloy. "But we don't have that now. ... We will not tolerate a police officer beating up his wife."

He did, however, insist that an accused officer should receive "due process" and not be fired, disciplined or removed from duty based on an allegation.

Advertise with us

'Zero tolerance'

Mayor Luke Ravenstahl pledged a "zero tolerance" policy toward domestic violence by any city workers after the June 18 promotions.

"This type of crime traditionally has not been treated like other kinds of crime," said Mr. Thomas, a former police corporal who teaches domestic violence-related courses in Johns Hopkins University's Police Executive Leadership Program. "Traditionally, this type of crime is not enforced against officers. ... They hem and they haw and they don't take it seriously."

Mr. Thomas worked for 15 years in Maryland's Montgomery County Police Department. He helped write the International Association of Chiefs of Police model policy on domestic violence, and has been a consultant to law enforcement on the topic for eight years.

Council held a June 28 public hearing on the promotions. Today's 1:30 p.m. meeting will be open to the public, but the only people allowed to comment will be invited guests, including Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., Mr. Malloy, Citizen Police Review Board Executive Director Elizabeth Pittinger, and representatives of women's shelters and advocacy organizations.

Advertise with us

"This is not a police-bashing thing," said council President Doug Shields, who set up the meeting. "We want to take a look at this to better understand the dynamic of domestic violence and the policy piece, and what we can do to make this better."

Police "take an oath to serve and protect," said Diane Wetendorf, a Chicago-based expert on officer-involved domestic violence who will not be at today's hearing. "It's different with cops because they have a position of public trust, because they respond to victims of domestic violence crimes."

New Cmdr. George T. Trosky was arrested in 1997 for breaking the nose of his then-wife, whose failure to appear in court led to charges being dropped. Also promoted were Lt. Charles Rodriguez, who saw his daughter drop simple assault charges against him in July, and Sgt. Eugene F. Hlavac, whose arguments with his girlfriend prompted two police calls to his home and anger management counseling this year.

None of the three officers promoted in June has had a PFA filed against him.

Those who have include patrol officers, detectives, sergeants, rookies and even veterans. Six of them were accused in PFAs before they joined the Pittsburgh police. Four officers were accused by more than one woman.

Advertise with us

All but one of the PFA petitioners are female, and they allege a range of behaviors that include choking, punching, kicking, shoving and holding them at gunpoint. Just one of the 34 PFA requests was denied by a judge. The others were granted for a wide variety of durations.

None of those officers or female petitioners is being mentioned by name by the Post-Gazette because PFAs are only accusations, not criminal charges.

The accused officers represent about 4 percent of the 846-member force.

In most cases, the officers accused of domestic violence were not arrested. And in the few cases for which arrests are indicated in civil court paperwork, no such arrests could be unearthed in criminal court records.

Assistant City Solicitor Kate De Simone, responding to written questions originally sent to Chief Harper, said the bureau "tracks this information on a case-by-case basis and employs safeguards."

Advertise with us

She declined to release any specific information about PFAs, arrests of officers, police responses to officers' homes for domestic situations, internal investigations, discipline or methods of tracking employees with possible domestic violence problems. She wrote that the information either was not maintained by the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police or did not fall under the purview of the state's Right to Know Act.

Mr. Malloy and Mr. Campbell warned against drawing conclusions about the officers involved in PFAs, which can be granted with a low burden of proof.

Determining the truth of a PFA complaint is notoriously difficult, both said.

In some cases, the parties file protection complaints against each other. And in some cases, particularly when young children are in the middle of a dispute, Mr. Campbell said a protection complaint is used as a legal tactic to wrest custody of the children from a spouse or otherwise avoid extended litigation.

Carrying a gun with a PFA

Advertise with us

Most people subject to long-term PFAs must surrender any guns they own and can't buy or carry any handguns.

Federal law provides an "official-use exemption" allowing police to carry a firearm while on duty, as long as a court approves.

One Pittsburgh officer currently under a PFA must sign his gun out from a station supervisor at the beginning of his shift and return it at the end.

A judge ordered him to turn over all of his multiple firearms and he had to petition for the right to use his service weapon.

Mr. Malloy described the court's decision as "ludicrous," questioning why a judge would take away an officer's private firearms on one hand but grant him his service weapon on the other if there is a bona fide worry he might be dangerous to others.

Advertise with us

The officer's attorney agreed.

"This was not an immediate incident of violent abuse," said the attorney, Patrick Nightingale. "He gets into a funk and says some things that are primarily self-destructive in nature, but because he's a police officer, people say he's got a gun, he's a problem."

Mr. Thomas strongly recommends a no-gun policy for officers subject to protection-from-abuse orders of any duration.

"If a court finds that the individual is a danger to somebody else, the liability you incur by continuing to allow them to go out there with a firearm is insane," he said. Cases have "occurred in which an officer under a protection order has gone out there and violated the order, murdering the petitioner and the kids. You've got better odds in Vegas.

"Divorce decree, custody issue decided or PFA -- that's when we see the violence go through the roof," he said. The officer might be able to access a gun some other way, he acknowledged; however, "we shouldn't be the ones putting the gun in their hand."

Advertise with us

If a PFA is filed, Mr. Malloy said, the chief of police is immediately notified even before it is served. If the officer is arrested, an internal hearing will be held within 10 days.

Investigating complaints

In most cases, the complaint will proceed through the Civil Division of Common Pleas Court. Mr. Campbell and Mr. Malloy said the city's Office of Municipal Investigations will send a representative to the PFA hearing and report back to the chief.

Ms. De Simone said OMI reads the reports filed by supervisors about protection orders against officers, "but at this point, the matter is one for the court system. Where appropriate, OMI will monitor the legal proceedings."

Bureaus should conduct a thorough investigation of any domestic violence allegation against an officer, and should be prepared to share some details of that inquiry, and its result, with the public, Mr. Thomas said. That benefits both the bureau, the public, and often, he said, the officer.

Advertise with us

"Let's say these three individuals who were promoted were, in fact, not guilty," he said. A thorough, transparent internal investigation gives the bureau "solid ground to stand on" when it defends the promotions.

Mr. Malloy said it would be unfair to base discipline on unproven allegations arising from a troubled marriage. The only equitable way to deal with domestic complaints, he said, is to let the court system decide.

Mr. Thomas said following the court's actions isn't sufficient. Whereas a criminal court demands that an accusation be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, he said, a bureau's internal decisions should be made on the basis of a preponderance of evidence.

A dropped criminal charge is "so cloudy," he said. "Just because an individual isn't criminally convicted doesn't mean there won't be a founded accusation, administratively, in the department."

If evidence supports the allegation, the level of discipline should be the same as if the violent act occurred outside of the home, Mr. Thomas said. If that would provoke a suspension or termination, the same should occur if the officer hit a family member.

Advertise with us

When police were twice called to the apartment of Sgt. Hlavac after loud and, in one case, physical confrontations involving his girlfriend, a commander recommended he be removed from active duty, undergo anger management counseling and his contact with the public minimized on his return. He was, however, never taken out of contact with the public.

Anger management counseling does not get to the root of the problem, said Ms. Wetendorf.

Abuse is "not an anger management issue," she said. "They should go to batterers counseling. We say that batterers are able to manage their anger very well. They don't hit their supervisors. They don't hit their chief. They keep it in check until they get home and they're with the one person who will not be believed or cannot make a report."