Three properties beside the Garden Theater in the Central North Side, which have been caught up in appeals litigation since 2016, are expected to be demolished, although a timeline has not been announced.

The Victorian-era buildings at 4, 6 and 8 West North Ave. were once key to a preservation-oriented development around the former porn theater. The Urban Redevelopment Authority was committed to saving them. When so much time had passed, it shifted its commitment to saving the facades and front portions.

Now the URA is committed to moving development forward without them. The city condemned the buildings in July.

Robert Rubinstein, executive director of the URA, said the passage of time, the expiration of tax-increment financing and fear for public safety led to the decision.

Advertise with us

“Demolition was not a choice for decades,” he said. “We tried everything we could.”

In 2016, Trek Development proposed saving the three facades as part of a new, 72-apartment development. The Zoning Board of Adjustment approved a variance for eight stories. Only three stories are allowed without variances.

Bill Gatti, president and CEO of Trek, said the height was the only way to make the estimated $2.7 million cost of saving and incorporating the facades pay off economically.

The Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas overturned the zoning decision on appeal. Trek appealed to Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court, which upheld the lower court’s decision.

The appeals “sent us back to the drawing board” with a scenario of many “what-ifs,” Mr. Rubinstein said. “We came to the conclusion that keeping Trek was beneficial. They have really responded for years to working with the community and its concerns.”

Advertise with us

The Garden Theater is fully renovated but has remained without a tenant because every potential tenant was afraid the adjacent building would fall on it, he said.

“We have worked for nearly five years to devise a preservation strategy for these three structures” as have other developers over two decades,” Mr. Gatti said. “There is no viable path forward for 4, 6 and 8 West North under the current zoning regulations.”

The URA and preservation groups are documenting the facades, history and architectural merit of the properties for posterity.

Meanwhile, the demolition notices have sparked discussions, including an epic thread on social media, with sentiments ranging from “good riddance” to continuing calls for preservation.

In fact, one such call came in an on-line letter signed by the original appellants against Trek’s plan to build high to save the facades, Stephen Pascal and David Demko. Mr. Pascal is a resident of New York who owns properties in the Central Northside and Deutschtown. Mr. Demko lives in the Central Northside.

Advertise with us

Their letter argues that a strong market could bear individual efforts to restore the endangered properties but that the URA’s agreement with Trek is a monopoly that waylays any such possibility.

The letter also claims a petition with 1,000 signatures has been raised as a result of the Allegheny City Central Association’s endorsement of the demolitions. The on-line petition at change.org has more than 1,300 signatures as of this report.

Patrick Dexter, president of the Allegheny City Central Association, wrote to the URA last summer that “our organization’s membership voted overwhelming ...that the demolition of 4, 6, and 8 W. North Avenue be considered as an option. We appreciate the investment that the URA has made into this block. We’re ready to build upon the successful renovation of the Bradberry [apartments] and Masonic Building [City of Asylum], and this requires a realistic assessment of the buildings that remain undeveloped.”

Preservation groups concur, “but the word I would use is regretfully,” said Matthew Craig, executive director of the Young Preservationists Association of Pittsburgh. ““Every one of us is wary going on record saying we support demolition. We don’t. But we are not going to fight it given the safety concerns.

“When you step inside, you don’t want to go any further,” he said, having taken a tour this summer. “It felt dangerous to me.”

Advertise with us

Matthew Falcone, board president of Preservation Pittsburgh, said his organization also has changed its outlook since touring the properties in late summer.

In a March letter to the URA, Preservation Pittsburgh’s vice-president Susan Brandt decried any plan for demolition, writing that the three buildings are part of a streetscape “that can never be replaced or recreated.”

She described 8 W. North as “an elegant example of the American Italianate style” whose masonry details on the upper three floors “remain remarkably intact.” 4 W. North is “a classic example” of the Romanesque Revival style.

“Now we have an understanding of the condition,” Mr. Falcone said, “and we’re very much in agreement that there are structural issues. It’s incredibly disheartening.

“There was a plan that tried to broker a middle ground to salvage part of the buildings,” he said, referring to Trek’s proposal. “That would have been preferable” to losing the facades.

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.