HARRISBURG -- The judicial showdown over the state's new natural gas drilling law begins this morning in Commonwealth Court, where municipal officials will be making their case as to why the statute's provisions regarding zoning rules and chemical confidentiality are unconstitutional.

Some observers believe that may be a steep burden for the plaintiffs, which include the towns of Cecil, Peters, Mount Pleasant and Robinson in Washington County, South Fayette in Allegheny County, as well as Bucks County officials, a Monroeville doctor and environmental activists.

They argue that the new law, which goes into full effect on Saturday, limits their ability to craft local zoning ordinances that adequately protect their residents.

The standardized rules for towns would allow shale gas drilling activity and compressor stations in some currently prohibited areas, which the officials allege will infringe on the rights of residents and discourage new development.

Advertise with us

The act gives towns 120 days to update their ordinances if they are not in compliance, although some attorneys and local officials say that creates a window of uncertainty as to the rules for drillers until updated regulations are in place.

They are seeking an injunction in part to clarify what can and cannot occur as the legal challenge winds through the court system.

"The main thing that [the hearing] can resolve for municipalities is the validation that the 120-day period that the law provides for means something," said Jordan Yeager, a Doylestown attorney involved in the challenge. "They're in this rush to dismantle the local democratic process."

A brief filed by the commonwealth on Tuesday argues in response that the municipalities in the suit have not shown how they would be harmed if the law goes into effect. It describes their legal claims as "nothing more than a broad criticism of the [law's] scope and effectiveness."

In addition to the zoning provision, the law approved in February also allows counties to enact a per-well fee to pay for local and state impacts and overhauls the state's environmental regulations.

Advertise with us

This morning's hearing before a Harrisburg judge was scheduled expeditiously in light of the statute's looming effective date. The judge could decide to grant the request to halt the law or could allow the debate over zoning rights to proceed through the legal system without interfering with the statute's timeline.

Several industry operators -- Chesapeake Appalachia, MarkWest Liberty Midstream and Resources, and Penneco Oil Co. Inc. -- as well as the Marcellus Shale Coalition, an industry trade group, have sought to intervene in the lawsuit. A hearing on that request has been scheduled for Tuesday morning.

"I don't think anyone expects the case to be resolved before the 14th," said Mr. Yeager, referring the law's enactment date.

The key argument for the challengers may be proving a constitutional issue with the law, said Ross Pifer, director of the Agricultural Law Resource and Reference Center at Penn State's Dickinson School of Law.

The local officials have claimed in part that the new law conflicts with the state's existing Municipal Planning Code, which governs local land use. Both are state statutes, and lawmakers do have the right to update earlier laws, Mr. Pifer said.

Advertise with us

A broader constitutional claim may be needed, he said. "The mere fact that rights granted to a municipality have been taken away likely won't be enough."

Still, the Corbett administration is cautiously eyeing the challenge to the law they spent months negotiating in private meetings with Republican legislative aides.

Asked if he was concerned about the lawsuit's hearing, Gov. Tom Corbett on Tuesday said: "Anybody who doesn't get concerned about litigation is making a mistake."

"We're going to watch [the lawsuit] very carefully," he said, following a tour of a custom millwork and casework company, Giffin Interior and Fixture Inc. in Bridgeville. "I wouldn't say I'm concerned about [the lawsuit]. But I believe the law is constitutional and I believe the law as the Legislature wrote it will prevail."

He said he could not comment about another claim in the lawsuit regarding a provision that would prevent doctors from disclosing certain proprietary chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing that they may gain knowledge of in the course of treating a patient.

The challenge alleges that the ability of doctors to properly treat their patients is compromised because of the nondisclosure requirement. Mr. Corbett said he's "not familiar enough with the details of the litigation personally to get into making speculation or comment about it."