When teacher Joyce Muchoney heard from a co-worker at Norwin High School about a local essay competition to create a sustainable space at Monroeville Mall, she never expected her AP environmental science students to sweep the competition — but they did just that.
The three 2021 Norwin graduates — Keara Finnigan, Brendan Ash and Nick Markovina — swept the Monroeville Mall EcoMall essay competition this summer. The competition was designed to reimagine the 169-acre mall and parking lot into a more economically, socially and environmentally sustainable space for the community and surrounding areas.
Hosted by Reimagine Turtle Creek Watershed & Airshed Communities, a community-led initiative created to implement sustainability solutions in the Allegheny and Westmoreland counties, the competition awarded Ms. Finnigan, Mr. Ash and Mr. Markovina the first-, second- and third-place prizes, respectively, for their efforts and ideas, completed with diagrams of their plans.
The winning essays were awarded cash prizes of $500, $350 and $150, respectively.
The idea came after the nonprofit partnered with Carnegie Mellon University students in the Heinz College of Information Systems and Public Policy to research sustainability in Monroeville.
“Some of the things they suggested were engaging with the community more, but also there was research of who lives in Monroeville and what kind of things the community would need,” Annie Deely, community organizer for the Turtle Creek nonprofit, said.
“They found that Monroeville, compared to other similar-sized communities, has disproportionately more young people and senior citizens,” she said, adding that their connection with the youth was the entire goal of the competition.
Students from Gateway, Franklin Regional and Norwin school districts, as well as Pittsburgh’s Creative and Performing Arts High School, submitted 11 essays that covered topics including adding a farmers market, rooftop and rain gardens, solar panels and a park.
Originally, the Norwin students were assigned to write the essays as a grade for Mrs. Muchoney’s class, as it coincided with the AP curriculum, but she encouraged the students to submit them for the competition once she read the ideas her students presented.
“The three students that went on to win were very excited about the essay contest right from the beginning, even the students who didn’t were interested. I thought all of the essays that were submitted to me were quite good,” Mrs. Muchoney said.
“The essay contest overlapped with a number of the concepts that we covered in class such as water management, — which is a huge issue in this area — as well as things like energy efficiency."
All three participants applied their learning in different ways, while also weaving in elements of their personal experiences growing up and shopping in the mall.
An employee at the mall, Ms. Finnigan proposed a farmers market, where local sellers could rent stalls or potentially buy out vacant storefronts within the mall. She could not be reached for comment.
Mr. Ash’s idea, he said, was way too big at first. Upon paring it down, he proposed a recreational park area in the parking lot that included native plants that made sense for the area.
“I’ve been going to the mall since I was a little kid, so being able to redesign it made me really happy. The first day we learned about the assignment, we figured out we had a month to do it, but I immediately started redesigning it,” Mr. Ash said, adding that finishing second in the contest meant a lot to him.
The third-place winner, Mr. Markovina, was excited to write about the mall he grew up going to, proposing rain gardens to address the stormwater runoff problem in the mall’s parking lot. He also included ideas for rooftop gardens and solar panels.
“It was a surprise to me that I ended up getting third place because by the time the contest ended I figured, ‘Aw man, I probably didn’t win,’ but I got the email a few days later that I did place. I was ecstatic that they read my essay and decided it was one of the best ideas for the mall,” he said.
Reimagine Turtle Creek Watershed & Airshed Communities welcomed the ideas as a part of its Re-Imagine Monroeville Mall project that began back in late 2019.
The project planned to introduce renewable energy systems, retrofitting techniques that exhibit green infrastructure, and promotion of the inclusion of sustainable businesses inside the mall — ultimately, bringing in green jobs and revenue to stimulate Monroeville’s economy, especially with the increase of online shopping.
“The mall itself is falling into a pattern of decline, but in case studies we’ve done, malls that invest in themselves and that make themselves unique by adding rain gardens or bringing in local business, they’ve made it past this hump,” the group’s Ms. Deely said.
To help with the vision, on July 21 the winners were welcomed to read abridged versions of their essays in a public showcase at the mall, while the Turle Creek nonprofit’s leaders spoke about their visions of sustainability.
Mr. Ash and Mr. Markovina attended, both feeling proud of their work and amazed at the minds within the organization.
“All the speakers were very powerful, especially some of the organizers. While it was a little bit of a smaller event, I think it made its impact on the community. One of the bigger ideas they seem to push is, the more you talk about Re-Imagine Monroeville Mall, the more likely it is to happen. It’s almost becoming a household name, and I completely agree with that philosophy,” Mr. Markovina said.
In the future, the group plans to continue pushing the idea of an EcoMall to community leaders and CBL Properties, which owns the mall, through meetings and funding projects to get the word out there.
“We’re still trying to get this off the ground. Funding sources is something we’re thinking about. It’s not unheard of that nonprofit organizations work with a private property owner, but that doesn’t mean it’s the easiest thing to navigate,” Ms. Deely said.
Zoe Stratos: zstratos@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.