Borough officials are considering a plan to acquire several properties near the corner of Monongahela Avenue and Irvine Street where they would construct a new borough building, but residents are unhappy about the project, which could cost more than $2 million, saying officials held most of their discussions in private meetings.

Officials say they also want to acquire a warehouse property on McCague Street, which would be used as a public works garage.

Among the properties that could be acquired is an automotive business owned by Martin Busch, a former member of the Swissvale Borough Council.

More than 60 citizens attended the March 6 council meeting and asked for an explanation of the plans. Current estimates on the project at these two sites total $2.29 million.

Advertise with us

According to the summary proposal presented by council, the purchase of the properties had been debated in executive sessions and the owners were contacted to assess the viability of acquisition. None of these proposals were presented to the public until last week’s council meeting, when a vote was taken to begin the property appraisal process.

“I think the borough has a track record of, if not obfuscation about what’s going on, at least not being proactive with communication and it’s another example of a lack of proactive communication,” said Swissvale Community Action member Nathan Shaulis.

“We’ve urged council members to consider more active participation in public commentary, our organization has held community listening sessions, they’re not that difficult and from what we’ve seen up there, the council had many opportunities to listen to the community and it was completely squandered.”

Instead, Swissvale council, in identical 5-2 votes, authorized a second appraisal of a warehouse property that includes 1927 McCague St. It also authorized the borough solicitor to prepare a purchase agreement for that property to be considered by the owners. Council president Michele Stanton, Julie Grose, Patricia Gionta, David Petrarca and Tim Ward voted yes, Abigail Salisbury and Darrell Rapp voted no.

There currently are two businesses that use the McCague Street property, an office supply company that uses it for storage and an auto detailing shop. The asking price for this property is $370,000. Both businesses would likely be moved or shuttered.

Advertise with us

Council also authorized a survey and appraisal of two other properties located at the corner property at the intersection of 1931 Monongahela Ave. and six vacant storefronts from 7405 to 7415 Irvine St.

Through a series of negotiations the Irvine Street and Monongahela Avenue properties -- which has two buildings and one operating business, Busch Brothers Tire Service – dropped its asking price from $750,000 to $225,000 provided the borough would be the landlord. The Busch Brothers lease runs through 2036.

Mr. Busch, the proprietor of Busch Brothers Tire Service, is a former member of Swissvale council. According to the proposal, his business would be moved to the McCague Steet property.

If the appraisals are approved, council would then vote to purchase and renovate the existing buildings.

According to its proposal, the core of the municipal building was erected in 1906 and had several additions over years, including the council chambers that were believed to be tacked on in the 1930s and a garage for public works vehicles in the 1950s. The latest renovation added an elevator in the 1990s.

Advertise with us

The fate of the current municipal building is unclear, but borough manager Clyde Wilhelm suggested it might be sold as a way to defray purchase and construction costs of the new facility.

Ms. Salisbury and Mr. Rapp wanted council to table the authorizations to move forward and instead keep every step of the plan open for discussion. They were voted down, 5-2, on each item they attempted to table.Ms. Stanton, Ms. Grose, Ms. Gionta, Mr. Petrarca and Mr. Ward, voted to move forward.

“I was not surprised at all considering the fact I’ve been on council a little more than seven years now and, given the experience of knowing these fellow members of council, I’m not surprised at all,” said Mr. Rapp. “I think that, until we begin to explore even more options than just one option, I’m going to continue to ask for delays.”

“I don’t know if I would call it backlash. I just think that (council members) disagreed with me,” Ms. Salisbury said. “We don’t make a big practice of tabling things, typically.

“We try to craft an agenda that we move the motions as necessary, but I believe in this particular situation, it just needed more discussion.”

Keith Barnes, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com