The Pennsylvania Supreme Court heard argument Wednesday to determine whether a Wilkinsburg man should stand convicted of kidnapping his own daughter.

Tex Ortiz, 35, was found guilty by a jury of both kidnapping and interference with custody of children in May 2015.

Last year, the state Superior Court overturned Ortiz's conviction on the kidnapping count, finding that the prosecution failed to prove each element of the crime. Specifically, a three-judge panel wrote, the District Attorney's office failed to show that Ortiz took his daughter "to facilitate the commission of another felony."

The prosecution claimed the underlying felony was interference with custody of children, but the Superior Court said using the count in that way “would eviscerate the purpose and effect of the [interference] statue, rendering those provisions irreconcilable.”

Advertise with us

Ortiz had been raising his then-2-year-old daughter following the mother's death in October 2014. But the maternal grandparents sought custody and filed an emergency petition in family court. Ortiz said he was not made aware of the emergency hearing, and when he did not appear, interim custody was awarded to the grandparents.

When Ortiz received messages a few days later that he was to turn over his daughter, he took her and fled. They were found in Altoona two weeks later.

The child was unharmed, and Ortiz was arrested.

Following his conviction, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel ordered Ortiz to serve 8 to 22 years in prison.

Ortiz appealed on three grounds, including that the penalty imposed was excessive.

Advertise with us

However, the Superior Court, in issuing its opinion last year, never got to the question of the sentence. Instead it vacated the conviction for kidnapping, as well as a mandatory order that Ortiz be required to register as a sex offender for the rest of his life, despite there being no allegations of any underlying sexual misconduct.

The Allegheny County District Attorney's office appealed, arguing that the Superior Court erred in finding the prosecution failed to present sufficient evidence to support the charge of kidnapping.

During argument Wednesday before the state Supreme Court, Assistant District Attorney Rebecca McBride argued that her office proved Ortiz knew he no longer had custody of his daughter when he took her, and that his reason for fleeing was to commit the felony charge of interfering with custody by her grandparents. Therefore, she said, they proved the elements of kidnapping.

She noted to the court that Pennsylvania's kidnapping statute makes no exception for parents who remove children - as does federal law - and therefore the charge applied to Ortiz.

Further, she argued that interference is a separate law for which Ortiz can also be charged. Kidnapping, she wrote in her brief, requires only that the child is removed a substantial distance and confined for a substantial period of time in a place of isolation, while interference requires only the act of taking.

Advertise with us

"It's the commonwealth's position that they're entirely different offenses," she told the court.

But Assistant Public Defender Victoria Vidt argued that her client did not take his daughter to facilitate a felony or flight, but to retain his parental bond with her.

"I don't think kidnapping of a minor is intended to apply here," she said.

Justice David Wecht told Ms. Vidt that interference is a felony charge.

"Why isn't that the end of the discussion here?"

Advertise with us

Ms. Vidt answered that the prosecution failed to prove the necessary intent for kidnapping, and using interference as the underlying felony is a circular argument.

The justice then asked if the issue is really about how prosecutors make charging decisions.

"What you're really asking us to do is monitor the prosecution's behavior," said Justice Kevin Dougherty. "That's not really our function."

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.