Monroeville council has denied the Gateway School District’s request to rezone the Gateway Middle School property from R-1 residential to C-2 business commercial.

Council voted 4-2 to deny the application for the property at 4450 Old William Penn Highway, citing a lack of knowledge as to what may eventually end up on the 26-acre site if the school district sells the property.

Linda Gaydos, Paul Caliari, Steve Duncan and Ron Harvey voted to deny the application while Nick Gresock and Tom Wilson voted to approve it. Jim Johns was absent from the Nov. 14 meeting.

“I don’t think I’d want to rezone a piece of property without knowing what’s going to be there,” Mr. Harvey said, adding that the C-2 zoning has a “long list” of permitted uses.

Advertise with us

The school district has not said when it intends to sell the property or what type of business might buy the property.

Mr. Harvey made the motion to deny the rezoning, adding he talked to real estate professionals in the area regarding rezoning before a property is sold and he said the consensus among real estate agents was that it was not likely to bring a higher value to the property if it were already rezoned.

He added that the only thing it would do would be to help a potential buyer “not have to come before us” to rezone the property.

Mr. Wilson was concerned that any potential developer of the property may see that council denied the rezoning and that could make it more difficult for the school district to sell it.

Ms. Gaydos said the reason he denied it was “because we don’t know what they want to put there. They could sell it to a nonprofit. They could put a casino there or a hospital,” she said, adding a hospital or nonprofit would be tax-exempt.

Advertise with us

The school district can still pursue selling the property and then either the school or the purchaser could come back before council to reapply for rezoning.

Gateway school board member Chad Stubenbort said on Nov. 15 that Monroeville’s planning commission recommended approval of the rezoning and that no questions were raised at council’s Nov. 9 study session meeting.

“I believe that council voting down a purely preliminary action by the school board to see what, if any interest, there is so that future boards have options is disheartening,” Mr. Stubenbort said.

“This may also be why the Westinghouse property and Tech One properties still lay vacant. This vote did nothing but hurt all stakeholders in Monroeville from seeing what our options really are,” Mr. Stubenbort added.

In other business at the meeting, council unanimously denied an application from Wilco Tango Foxtrot Properties of Monroeville to subdivide one lot into three lots. The property at 2507 Haymaker Road is at the corner of a private road called Kaiser Drive and is about 1.7 acres. The owner wanted to subdivide it into three lots, each one about a half-acre.

Advertise with us

Council cited concerns about having more cars pulling out of Kaiser Drive onto busy Haymaker Road.

“That exit onto Haymaker is dangerous,” Ms. Gaydos said.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.