This is the kind of neighborhood Debbie McKillop will be losing: Just after the moving truck left Ellwood Avenue in Plum 25 years ago, a new neighbor crossed the street in the rain to deliver a vat of homemade soup to welcome her.
“There’s no amount of money you could give me that could replace this,” Ms. McKillop said last week as she sat on her porch looking over the small neighborhood. “We’re in the ideal location right here.”
But she and 11 of her neighbors likely will move out by the end of the year as part of a Pennsylvania Turnpike project to replace three bridges on local roads in anticipation of a turnpike widening project in the next decade. Their neighborhood just off Unity Trestle Road is one of two sites in Plum that will have serious disruption as part of the bridge projects, the other being the Plum Aqua Club on Saltsburg Road, which will close because it is losing access to its swim club, picnic area and locker room building.
The turnpike is planning a 7.5-mile, $217 million project to expand the toll road from four lanes to six lanes in Monroeville, Plum and Oakmont — part of its effort to rebuild the road across the state. To prepare for that work, the turnpike will replace bridges on local road that cross the existing toll road because they will be too short when the highway is widened.
In all three cases — Saltsburg Road (spring 2018), Unity Trestle Road (fall 2019) and Center Road in Monroeville (2020) — the bridges will be built beside the existing structures to maintain traffic and the roads will be relocated to meet the new bridges.
“I thought I was far enough from the turnpike that I might be skipped,” said Wilma Elicker, who delivered that soup to the McKillops 25 years ago and has lived on Ellwood for 63 years.
She grew up in neighboring Penn Hills, but her late husband, George, is from a long-standing Plum family that has a prominent borough road named after it.
The Elicker home sits close enough to the bridge and the existing turnpike that Mrs. Elicker received a notice about six months ago that it will be taken. Homes in the neighborhood have been appraised, but the turnpike hasn’t made offers to buy the properties yet.
“When we moved here, the turnpike bothered us the first night, then we got used to it,” said Mrs. Elicker, who shares the three-bedroom home with her granddaughter. “We never had any problem with the turnpike” before receiving the notice that she will have to move.
Mrs. Elicker said she will rely on her son, who recently moved back to the area from Florida, to help her clear the home and find a new place to live.
“I know I’m going to have to get rid of a lot,” she said. “I’m going to lose some good neighbors. Whenever I need anything, they’re here for me.”
About 120 members will lose the Plum Aqua Club, a fixture in the community since 1966. The club operates as a tax-paying, not-for-profit organization, and members, who become stockholders when they pay their $300 fee, voted recently to dissolve the organization, secretary Christine Montgomery said.
The primary reason the club is closing is because its steep driveway begins only a few feet from the existing bridge and a longer bridge will eliminate access to the site. But Ms. Montgomery, who has been on the board for 10 years and served as secretary the past four, said membership has been declining in recent years.
“It’s a bad driveway to begin with,” she said. “We suspect if you tried to build it today it wouldn’t be approved because the sight lines are so bad. [The operation] has been a struggle for a few years.”
The club is in negotiations with the turnpike on the sale price and has hired a Harrisburg attorney to represent its interests. When the initial offer came in at $940,000 — not even half of what the club has estimated it would need to acquire land and build at another site — the membership decided to close at the end of the season, Ms. Montgomery said.
The turnpike also bought an abandoned farm on the other side of Saltsburg from the Thomas J. Puskarich Trust for $223,000.
In Monroeville, the turnpike will acquire one undeveloped property and part of another property on Old Frankstown Road.
Jeanmarie McLaughlin, the turnpike’s assistant counsel, said the agency tries to acquire only the property it needs for a project. The process begins with the agency sending property owners a notice of acquisition, followed by an appraisal of the property’s value and an offer.
If the owner rejects the offer, the parties can negotiate a settlement. If that’s unsuccessful, the agency can issue a declaration of taking that allows it to acquire the property immediately with the owner having the right to challenge the payment in court.
Ms. McLaughlin said the commission won’t take the swim club until after its season ends.
Sometimes the commission closes the local road for bridge replacements like these, project manager Wayne Shappell said. But in this case, he said, the roads are so busy that the commission decided to build the replacement bridges beside the existing structures so traffic can be maintained through most of the work. Although that sometimes involves taking more property, it is less disruptive to the general public, he said.
In the case of Ellwood Avenue, the property is needed for both the bridge replacement and highway expansion, he said.
For Ms. McKillop, 52, and her husband, Todd, 56, the upcoming relocation is creating a crossroads in their lives.
On the one hand, it’s a good time for downsizing, she said, and there’s some excitement that comes with a new beginning. On the other, it’s hard to walk away from the memories on Ellwood, from the street parties to the “Zeus” tree planted after their first Doberman pinscher died.
“It’s hard to believe none of this is going to be here any more,” she said.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.