As he sent to prison the last of three Plum High School teachers convicted of having sexual relationships with their students, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman had harsh words Wednesday for the district, calling it a “cesspool.”
“There are a lot of other people besides you who should have been indicted,” he told former substitute teacher Michael Cinefra, who pleaded guilty to having a sexual relationship with a 15-year-old.
The judge noted that the “old boys network” is alive and well at Plum.
“You’re picking on juveniles. You’re picking on juveniles because they’re defenseless,” he said. “As teachers, you are supposed to be role models and protectors.”
Judge Cashman also criticized the district’s leadership, which, he pointed out, is still in place.
Contacted after the sentencing, Plum superintendent Timothy Glasspool said he had no comment.
Read More
The Allegheny County investigating grand jury issued an 89-page report in May outlining information that school administrators long knew about allegations that one teacher, Joseph Ruggieri, had been having sex with students. But no one ever took those concerns to law enforcement officials. Instead, the district did its own internal investigation.
Although the grand jury found fault all around, none of it was enough to lead to criminal charges against administrators. The allegations at Plum became public in early 2015, when Jason Cooper, a former science teacher, and Ruggieri, a former English teacher, were arrested, but the circumstances that led to that dated back years, the grand jury found.
Cinefra, 30, was later charged from information gathered by the grand jury. He pleaded guilty in November to involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, unlawful contact, institutional sexual assault, corruption of minors and furnishing alcohol to minors.
Judge Cashman ordered him, as part of a plea agreement, to serve three to six years in prison
Cooper is serving 18 to 36 months for institutional sexual assault and witness intimidation; Ruggieri is serving two to five years for institutional sexual assault, corruption of minors and witness intimidation.
“I didn’t like the plea agreement in the first case. I didn’t like the plea agreement in the second case. I don’t like the plea agreement in the third case,” Judge Cashman said. “Given my druthers, those three would be looking at decades.”
But, he continued, going to trial would have traumatized the victims again.
“I recognize they’ve had to purge themselves of your sins, and I’m not going to put them through that.”
The victim in Cinefra’s case submitted a letter to the court, telling Judge Cashman that the defendant took advantage of a young girl. Still, she continued, “I have dealt with my feelings and concerns and truly believe that I have moved on from this situation in a healthy way.”
In addition to the prison term, Cinefra will serve 10 years of probation, has surrendered his teaching certificate and must register for the rest of his life as a sex offender.
He apologized for his actions, saying, “It was the biggest mistake of my life.”
Defense attorney Patrick Thomassey said his client’s actions have been devastating.
“He let himself down, his family, his profession and the school district,” Mr. Thomassey said. “He’s from Day One taken responsibility for his actions. He’s ruined his life. He knows it.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.