A teenager who opened fire on a rival at Monroeville Mall last year and hit two bystanders is guilty, his lawyer said Wednesday, but mentally ill.

“This is a young man who needs treatment,” said Chris Urbano, who represents Tarod Thornhill, 18, of Penn Hills. “He is someone who can be rehabilitated.”

Mr. Urbano was addressing Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning, who is trying Mr. Thornhill without a jury for attempted homicide, aggravated assault and a host of other charges.

A jury had been selected over the past two days and the case was set to start Wednesday morning.

Advertise with us

But after several delays, Mr. Thornhill elected a bench trial and the judge sent the jury home.

Lawyers on both sides then made bare-bones opening statements devoid of the theatrics often reserved for a jury.

Mr. Thornhill is accused of shooting and wounding Davon Jones and wounding Thomas Singleton and his wife, Mary, inside Macy’s on Feb. 7, 2015.

Mr. Jones was hit three times and the Singletons once each.

Ilan Zur, the prosecutor, said Mr. Thornhill and Mr. Jones were enemies from previous encounters.

Advertise with us

He said Mr. Thornhill intended to kill Mr. Jones because he saw him at Macy’s, then went out to his car to get his gun and came back to start shooting. Surveillance cameras showed him firing as Mr. Jones ran away.

The Singletons, who were shopping with their young son, had the bad luck to be walking between the shooter and the target.

Mr. Urbano said he is not arguing that his client didn’t do it, although he said he will challenge the attempted homicide charge.

He said he will present evidence that Mr. Thornhill was mentally ill at the time of the incident, when he was 17. His main witness will be Alice Applegate, a psychologist. The prosecution will present its own expert.

“We’re not looking for a pass here, your honor,” Mr. Urbano said. “What happened was horrible and there is great remorse by my client.”

Advertise with us

A potential problem with a mental illness defense is a jailhouse phone recording between Mr. Thornhill and an unidentified woman in which she instructs him to act “nuttier than a fruitcake” when being examined by a doctor. The tape was played at a previous hearing.

The trial will resume today.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com