A jury on Monday convicted a Wilkinsburg man of third-degree murder in the death of his infant daughter two years ago after a trial that focused mostly on the testimony of his ex-girlfriend, the baby’s mother.
Jurors deliberated about two hours before finding Lincoln Levys guilty of killing Saige Levys, who was five weeks old when she died on Oct. 23, 2014.
The jury also convicted Levys of assaulting the baby and another of his children, but not guilty of assaulting a third. Jurors found him guilty of endangering all three children and possession of marijuana after police found a growing operation in the basement of the home he shared with his girlfriend, Sheena Alston.
The district attorney’s office said Saige died after enduring what Assistant District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni called a “constellation of injuries” inflicted by Levys, 29. In addition to trauma to her body, she suffered from gouge marks on her cheeks that the prosecution believes were caused by his fingernails.
Levys’ lawyers declined comment after the verdict.
Levys, who had been absent from the courtroom during the trial because he refused to cooperate, said nothing when Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph Williams III had deputies bring him to court to hear the decision.
“Take him away,” the judge said.
Closing arguments centered on the testimony of Ms. Alston, who said Levys abused the baby and the other children and that she was too cowardly to stop him.
Heath Leff, one of Levys’ lawyers, told the jury she’s not credible. He said she pleaded guilty to endangering her three children and agreed to testify in the hopes of consideration in her own case.
“Sheena lied over and over again,” he said. “There’s no evidence Lincoln did any of these things unless you find her completely credible.”
Ms. Alston said at trial that Saige was fine in the weeks before her death and that she thought the marks on her face were a rash. She also told detectives that she fed the baby and changed her diaper early on the morning of Oct. 23, but she later changed her story to say Levys had been the baby’s caretaker for the 24 hours leading up to her death.
Mr. Leff said Ms. Alston was trying to portray herself as another victim of Levys to deflect suspicion from herself.
Ms. DiGiovanni said Ms. Alston knew of the abuse, which is why she was charged with endangerment, but said she was a victim of abuse in her own childhood and did not know any other way to handle the situation.
She also said Alston’s story of Levys’ abuse was supported by medical evidence. She said Levys would hold Saige’s face down in one hand and hit her on the back with the other. Autopsy results were consistent with that description.
Ms. DiGiovanni said Levys never said Ms. Alston abused the children and admitted that he beat the older children. In one case, he hit one of them in the face with a hose for breaking his glass marijuana pipe.
Ms. DiGiovanni also said that when Ms. Alston was being questioned at police headquarters on the day of Saige’s death, Levys kept screaming at her from another room to not talk to the police.
“That’s consciousness of guilt,” she said.
Levys faces up to 40 years behind bars when he is sentenced in December.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.