Monroeville police have charged a local deputy fire chief with impersonating a police officer by using flashing lights to make a traffic stop.
George Fred Gerstacker. 46, of Monroeville was charged Tuesday by summons with impersonating a public servant and official oppression. Police said he pretended to be a police officer when he pulled over Alessandro Polito last week.
“Polito states that Gerstacker approached him claiming multiple traffic violations and stated that Gerstacker was very aggressive and pushy,” the complaint states. “Gerstacker was rushing Polito about his documentation suggesting that Polito did not have it.”
Neither Mr. Gerstacker nor Mr. Polito could not be reached for comment.
The incident occurred Sept. 13 around 5:15 p.m. at William Penn Highway and Golden Mile Highway when police say Mr. Gerstacker, driving a vehicle with flashing red and blue lights and the license plate EMT-1, pulled over Mr. Polito.
A short time earlier, according to police, Mr. Gerstacker used his fire radio to contact the Monroeville 911 center to notify them of an erratic driver on a motorcycle speeding past cars on a double yellow line.
Monroeville police Officer Keith Pascarella responded but could not spot the motorcycle. A short time later, the dispatch center asked the officer to come to the station. Mr. Polito had called to report that he was pulled over by someone he thought was a police officer “but wasn’t sure and wanted us to know,” the complaint said.
Officer Pascarella checked the license plate of the vehicle that stopped Mr. Polito and found it was registered to Mr. Gerstacker, the complaint said. He is identified as a former Monroeville police and fire dispatcher, a volunteer firefighter and the assistant chief of Station 5 in the community. Mr. Polito said he wanted to pursue charges.
On a recorded 911 line, Mr. Gerstacker said “that he pulled the motorcycle over and obtained his information. He was requesting to know who was on duty and stated that he wanted to have this individual cited,” the complaint said.
Mr. Polito provided a written statement Friday. It said that Mr. Gerstacker pulled alongside him on the shoulder, waving his arms for him to pull over. When he did, the complaint said. Mr. Gerstacker accused him of multiple traffic violations.
Mr. Polito said he gave Mr. Gerstacker a permit and driver’s license.
“Polito stated that he told Gerstacker that he was with the requirements for a permit and that Gerstacker stated I don’t need you to tell me the law and that he was well aware of the law.
“Polito states that Gerstacker returned to his vehicle, wrote down his information and returned to him asking about his updated address, his reason for being in Monroeville, his place of employment and phone number. Gerstacker then informed Polito that he would be receiving a citation in the mail.”
Officer Pascarella noted in the complaint that Mr. Gerstacker did not tell anyone that he had stopped Mr. Polito or tell the 911 dispatcher the location of the stop. The officer noted that he could have intervened had Mr. Gerstacker told him where he was.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.