For years, stories about former Plum high school teacher Joseph Ruggieri’s conduct with certain young ladies in his classes were an open secret and the subject of endless speculation.

Students, teachers and even top administrators right on up to the superintendent were suspicious. During a meeting Oct. 30, 2014, two union officials told superintendent Timothy Glasspool about a rumor on social media that Ruggieri was having sex with a student. “That’s not the rumor I heard,” he supposedly said, according to an Allegheny County grand jury report released Thursday. “I heard that [a recent graduate] is living in his basement.”

Over and over, the report said, administrators were brought persistent rumors about Ruggieri and commenced their own investigations absent any formal training.

But no adults in a position of authority called police or relayed their suspicions in any meaningful way, the grand jury said. With few exceptions, teachers and administrators, according to the report, either did nothing, not enough or the wrong thing. Handling reports of possible criminal conduct internally and not involving police was the standard operating procedure, according to the grand jury.

Advertise with us

The report described how Ruggieri — a high school English teacher and teachers union official — was able to get away with having sex with one of his students and survive years of widespread suspicion about his alleged relationships with other students.

Ruggieri, now in prison for institutional sexual assault after being convicted in April in a plea deal, is described in the report as a “suspected serial child predator.” Another former high school teacher, Jason Cooper, went to prison in March for having sex with a different student. Their arrests — along with that of a third teacher, Drew Zoldak, for allegedly intimidating Ruggieri’s victim — plunged the Plum Borough School District and the community into months of self-examination.

Top among those targeted for grand jury criticism was Ryan Kociela, the high school principal, and Mark Kost, the former school resource officer.

“Kociela had known of ‘rumors’ of Ruggieri and numerous female students for years, and yet never documented any of those matters, never contacted a counselor to assist any of the female students, never notified police, never notified ChildLine [the state child abuse hotline], never notified Allegheny County Children, Youth and Family Services, and never reprimanded Ruggieri,” the report said.

Mr. Kost was faulted for poor documentation and a lack of initiative to investigate.

Advertise with us

“While fault is fairly placed on administration for not involving law enforcement where there existed clear allegations of criminal conduct, it cannot be ignored that one likely reason for not involving Officer Kost may have simply been due to Kost’s own lack of effectiveness and competence as a police officer,” the report said.

The grand jury did not directly blame Mr. Glasspool or his predecessor, Lillian Naccarati, for how the situations were handled. “The grand jury is cognizant of documentary evidence from Dr. Glasspool indicating that he was acting upon the advice of legal counsel in some of the decisions that he had made,” the report said.


EDITOR’S NOTE: This document contains graphic language

Plum-Grand-Jury-Report-Plus-Responses (PDF)

Plum-Grand-Jury-Report-Plus-Responses (Text)

Advertise with us

“I dispute the accuracy of some of the testimony in the presentment,” Mr. Glasspool wrote in an email. “Nonetheless, there is no advantage attempting to correct these inaccuracies and conclusions referenced in the presentment, as the goal is to move forward. The Plum Borough School District has cooperated with the investigation and continues to do so. ...”

District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. launched the grand jury investigation to learn whether school administrators “ignored warning signs and allowed a child predator to continue his employment in the high school,” the report said. Although not recommending new criminal charges — a former substitute teacher, Michael Cinefra, was arrested months ago out of evidence arising from the investigation — the grand jury laid out what happened in extraordinary detail.

Each year, the report said, Ruggieri would “pick a new girl.” Grand jurors heard from at least five female graduates from as far back as 2007. Although most did not admit to having sexual contact with Ruggieri, the grand jury said it considered all of them victims. Ruggieri engaged in what the grand jury termed “grooming” — spending “exorbitant” amounts of time with young women outside of class. But neither Mr. Kociela nor Mr. Kost “made any efforts to identify the pattern or put a stop to this predatory behavior by a teacher with the very walls of the school itself.”

Attorneys for Ruggieri, Mr. Kociela and Mr. Kost all declined to comment.

Since the scandal became public in February 2015 with the arrests of Ruggieri and Cooper, one overriding set of questions has concerned the community: Who knew what, when and what did they do about it?

Advertise with us

According to the grand jury: Lots of people, a long time ago, and not enough.

“This grand jury is appalled that Ruggieri was permitted to simply continue his pattern of behavior with absolutely no oversight by administration and with seemingly little or no concern for the children entrusted to the district’s care. It is incomprehensible that any individual in a supervisory position over professional educators would disregard such a clear continuity of conduct by a teacher at the risk of the safety of the children the district is entrusted to educate and protect.”

In its 89-page report, the grand jury documented years of “systematic failures.” The report described how Mr. Kociela opted to make inquiries about Ruggieri on his own rather than contacting authorities. Even after Plum police became involved in February 2015, the report said, Mr. Kociela did not share information until the lead detective, Mark Focareta, confronted him with questions about Ruggieri and the rumored victim that he had gleaned independently from interviews.

“We attribute these failures in large part to an academic culture that encouraged the protection of friends and colleagues over students, insularity, avoidance of personal responsibility in favor of shifting the onus onto others without follow up, and turning a blind eye to obvious signs of teacher misconduct,” the report said.

After interviewing 30 witnesses, reviewing 7,500 pages of documents and digging through more than 55 gigabytes of data, the grand jury laid out the lengths to which teachers, union officials, the high school’s former resource officer and top administrators went to handle allegations of abuse and not involve law enforcement.

Advertise with us

Indeed, in 2012 Mr. Glasspool, upon receiving a report about Ruggieri’s behavior with a female student, stated that “this report would not be the first to prompt him to have a conversation with Ruggeri about an inappropriate relationship...” A guidance counselor testified that she notified Mr. Kociela of rumors about Ruggieri about 10 times in one year. And Mr. Kociela himself said he alerted Ms. Naccarati in 2011, as well as solicitor Lee Price.

The grand jury said it was “disturbing” that “despite so much suspicion and concern over the potential of an illicit relationship between a teacher and a student” there were no records in either Ruggieri’s or the student’s files.

Any inquiry was handled internally. In the case of the student mentioned in the 2011 and 2012 complaints — referred to as Victim 3 — the woman denied to administrators and later to the grand jury that she had sex with Ruggieri. Last year, however, she told Plum police “‘even if I did, I’d take that to the grave... It’s been like three years so why do you even care? I mean I didn’t have sex, but if I did, it’s been like three years. Why not lie?’”

And as for the case of the student whose relationship with Ruggieri sent him to prison? The report said Mr. Glasspool told union president Martha Freese via an email that was never located that the rumors were “unfounded.” Mr. Kociela told a guidance counselor that Ruggieri and the young woman were not allowed to be in the same room together. But the two “were simply left on their honor to police their own whereabouts within the building.”

The grand jury said the failure of Mr. Kociela, Mr. Glasspool and Mr. Kost to contact ChildLine about Ruggieri could constitute a crime.

Advertise with us

“However, as an Investigative body we are not convinced that the conscious objective of the staff and administration of Plum Borough School District was to purposely put children at risk. Rather, the course of conduct described herein seems to be the product of a dysfunctional culture fostered by administration’s concern for their peers and the reputation of the educational institution over and above their statutory obligation,” the report concluded. “In the matter involving Joseph Ruggieri, a timely report submitted in 2011 may well have prevented other students from becoming victims.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.