A fraud case against an Oakmont developer that has featured sparring among prosecutor, judge and defense attorney ended peacefully Tuesday as most federal cases do — with a guilty plea.

Louis Lamanna, 50, of Hulton Road admitted to two counts related to structuring and reporting financial transactions. Other counts of bankruptcy fraud, money laundering and conspiracy were dismissed.

The case was unusual, at least by staid federal court standards, in that U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab had previously ruled that the U.S. Attorney’s office violated Lamanna’s rights by bringing charges the judge had already thrown out.

His lawyer, David Berardinelli, also had accused Assistant U.S. Attorney Brendan Conway of “vindictive prosecution.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Conway had been set to testify on the second issue, but the whole thing became moot after the parties worked out a plea deal, this time with Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Comber stepping in to handle the affair.

Federal agents say Lamanna hid his assets from bankruptcy, including his bank accounts and a car, and conspired with family members to structure more than $170,000 in withdrawals from banks to avoid currency transaction reports.

The case began in 2011, when he was indicted for tax evasion. He was indicted again that same year for tax evasion, money laundering and bankruptcy fraud. He worked out a plea deal before Judge Schwab in 2012, but after that the U.S. Attorney’s office brought a third case against him for failure to pay income taxes.

He pleaded to that charge and the parties agreed that the 2011 case would be dismissed. Judge Schwab sentenced him in November 2012 to a year behind bars and ordered him to pay $708,000 in restitution.

But before he reported to prison, prosecutors said, he sold about $375,000 in business assets and didn’t tell anyone as he and his family withdrew some of the money in increments under $10,000 to avoid bank reporting requirements.

Advertise with us

The U.S. Attorney’s office said that conduct violated the 2012 plea agreement.

Prosecutors then brought a new indictment that included the same bankruptcy and money-laundering counts that Judge Schwab had dismissed.

The judge threw out the charges in February because he said he’d already tossed them as part of the plea deal. He said Mr. Conway should have just filed a motion about the plea being breached instead of a new indictment.

Yet on the same day as that ruling, Mr. Conway brought yet another indictment that included the same dismissed counts, which meant Lamanna has been charged three times for the same offenses.

Judge Schwab said that wasn’t fair and threw them out once again.

Advertise with us

Mr. Berardinelli later accused Mr. Conway of acting vindictively.

Mr. Conway explained in court papers that he didn’t contravene the judge’s orders by reindicting but had already secured the indictment before realizing the judge had ruled. He said he didn’t learn of the dismissal until he had left the grand jury room and another prosecutor told him of the decision.

In the end, Mr. Comber took over the case and handled the plea, after which Judge Schwab made a point in court to thank him.

Lamanna will be sentenced in October. He faces six months in prison and another six months on home confinement.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.