A private meeting last week attended by a trio of Plum school directors, the borough police chief, district superintendent and other school administrators became a public issue this week.

At Tuesday’s school board meeting, school director Sue Caldwell called out Superintendent Timothy Glasspool for organizing a closed-door meeting the morning of Feb. 9. Only a handful of board members were invited to discuss school safety issues with Police Chief Jeffrey Armstrong.

“I think it’s best we have a very transparent and open form of leadership in our district now and I had concerns that this wasn’t the best example of transparent leadership, said Mrs. Caldwell, who took office in December

She said she decided to make a public statement about the meeting “because I knew about it and I knew it wasn’t right.”

Advertise with us

In the past year, three teachers from Plum High School have been charged with institutional sexual assault and a fourth was charged with intimidating one of the alleged witnesses. The teachers’ trials start next month.

In addition, the district is awaiting the outcome of an Allegheny County grand jury investigation into the scandal that is expected to wrap up at the end of this month.

Mrs. Caldwell said she heard about the private meeting through conversations with other school directors and she called solicitor Lee Price to see why it was a private meeting. “He said there was not a reason for this meeting to be closed,” Mrs. Caldwell said. Mr. Price confirmed that conversation.

In the wake of the teacher sex scandal, the school board formed a Safe and Supportive Schools committee, which sponsors a citizens advisory steering committee. Through the two committees, residents and school officials hold frequent discussions on school safety initiatives.

Mr. Glasspool said he organized it for the chief to talk about school security issues with some board members in preparation for the Feb. 10 steering committee meeting the following day and that issued invitations based on who he believed was available.

Advertise with us

Mr. Glasspool said it “wasn’t my intent to exclude or deceive any board member” and that he intended to report on the closed-door meeting at the next meeting of the board but said Mrs. Caldwell made her statement first.

The superintendent said he wanted to discuss “sensitive school security issues” at the meeting and that under the law he can’t call an executive session to discuss security “but I can have a meeting that is less than a quorum to talk about anything at any time.”

Invited to the meeting by Mr. Glasspool were four school directors -- Sal Colella, Kevin Dowdell, Michelle Gallagher and Vicky Roessler. The number was one shy of a quorum. Mr. Dowdell did not attend but the others did.

Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania News Media Association, said that “technically” inviting fewer than a quorum of board members to a meeting is not a violation of the state Open Meeting Law.

“But you can’t intentionally avoid a quorum to intentionally avoid public access,” Ms. Melewsky said. “If I were a member of that school board I’d want to know what my school safety plan is and what my police chief says about it. That seems like important things to know.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Colella said he doesn’t understand why the meeting was held because the same issues discussed at the private meeting were discussed at the next night’s public steering committee meeting.

Those issues included the chief outlining the school resource officers duties in the high school and middle school as opposed to those of the proposed school safety coordinator -- a position that will be on the agenda for a board voted on Feb. 23.

Mrs. Roessler, who chairs the board’s Safe and Supportive Schools committee and the citizen’s steering committee, said this of the private meeting: “I did not call the meeting and there was no ill intent on my part.”

Mary Niederberger; mniederberger@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590.