An Allegheny County Common Pleas judge has pushed back trial dates for four teachers charged as part of an investigation into inappropriate sexual relationships at Plum High School so that prosecutors have enough time to sort through grand jury materials and turn over anything exculpatory to the defense.

During a hearing Friday afternoon, Judge David R. Cashman told former Plum teachers Jason Cooper, Joseph Ruggieri and Michael Cinefra, as well as suspended teacher Drew Zoldak, that the grand jury investigating Plum has at least one more session before it will close. That means that the trials for the men, scheduled to start with Mr. Zoldak on Feb. 8, will have to be delayed, the judge said.

Technically, Judge Cashman explained, the defendants could waive their rights to receive the grand jury material, but he said that was not a viable option.

“The first alternative is unacceptable to me because all that’s doing is putting grounds together for post-conviction relief,” the judge said.

Advertise with us

Judge Jill E. Rangos, who is the supervising judge for the grand jury, attended the hearing. She would not give a firm date for the panel’s expiration but said she believed that the prosecution could review all of the relevant materials within a week of the grand jury’s last session.

“This particular investigation will conclude by the end of February,” she said.

Mr. Zoldak, who is charged with intimidating a witness for allegedly singling out Mr. Ruggieri’s alleged victim in class, is now scheduled for trial on March 14.

“We’re gratified this matter is coming to trial,” said his defense attorney, Alexander Lindsay Jr.

Mr. Cooper, who is charged with institutional sexual assault and related charges and is being held in the Allegheny County Jail, will go to trial on March 30, and Mr. Ruggieri, also charged with institutional sexual assault and being held at the jail, is now set for April 18.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cinefra, the last of the defendants to be charged, is the only one to keep his original trial date, which is scheduled for April 25.

The prosecutor who will try the cases also has changed. Assistant district attorney Evan Lowry, who became a prosecutor in 2010, is leaving the DA’s office to work in private practice as a civil litigator. He will be replaced on the Plum cases by assistant district attorney Brian Catanzarite.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.