A seven-year investigation into chronic thefts at Barnes & Noble stores in Allegheny County led to the arrest Wednesday of a Wilkins record store owner accused of using drug addicts to steal a panoply of items from various retail stores so he could resell them online.

Anthony J. Cicero, 50, of Wilkins was charged Wednesday by the state attorney general’s office with illegally making more than $2 million since 2009.

“This defendant not only cost retail stores millions in lost inventory, but he also enabled and fed the drug addictions of multiple individuals,” Attorney General Kathleen Kane said. “This was a case where the defendant exploited others at every turn.”

He was polite about it to his customers, though. A grand jury presentment said Mr. Cicero sent the stolen goods to buyers with a “personalized note … thanking them for the purchase.”

Advertise with us

Investigators said Mr. Cicero, the owner of the Slipped Disc record store in Oakland, operated several illegitimate business accounts on Amazon and eBay to resell merchandise stolen from a variety of stores, including Barnes & Noble, CVS, Rite Aid, Giant Eagle, Staples and Wal-Mart.

Mr. Cicero was charged following a lengthy investigation launched by a Barnes & Noble investigator, who in 2008 began probing the chronic theft of thousands of dollars of merchandise in Allegheny County.

Eventually the investigation grew to involve the attorney general’s office, undercover controlled transactions, informants and a statewide investigating grand jury. In June the grand jury recommended criminal charges.

Investigators identified the online businesses Media Play USA, Rosemary’s Baby and Slipped Disc as the entities Mr. Cicero used to move the stolen merchandise.

Search warrants that were executed last year on the Slipped Disc and Mr. Cicero’s home on Cline Street turned up more than $44,000 of new merchandise, including some that had been surreptitiously marked by investigators during controlled transactions, the grand jury presentment said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cicero is charged with two counts of corrupt organizations and one count each of theft by unlawful taking, receiving stolen property, criminal conspiracy and organized retail theft.

He was arraigned and bail was set at $50,000 unsecured.

A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Sept. 14.

The criminal complaint names six people accused of conspiring with Mr. Cicero and acting as “boosters,” or the people who actually stole merchandise, including the LEGO sets, graphic novels, books, DVDs, toys, diet supplements, cosmetics and electronic equipment.

There is no indication that any of them have been charged in connection with this investigation.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cicero could not be reached for comment; neither could his attorney, who is listed in court records as Charles Porter Jr.

Court records indicate that Mr. Porter also represented Mr. Cicero in 1999 when he pleaded guilty to misdemeanor counts of retail theft and simple assault. He was sentenced to up to a year in jail.

Editor's note: Portions of this criminal complaint against Mr. Cicero have been redacted, as the alleged co-conspirators have not been charged.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.