Gene Montemurro has been repairing shoes for more than six decades but has never considered retirement until now.

Age has nothing to do with it; the 82-year-old cobbler is still devoted to his craft, but after four attempted robberies to his New Kensington shop in 2014 and one successful robbery last week, his safety is an important factor.

“The pressure from my family to retire is unbelievable,” he said. “One hundred percent, they want me to quit. Sooner or later, I have to make a decision.”

While police look for suspects in Friday’s robbery, Mr. Montemurro is weighing his options. He could retire and ensure his own safety — which is most important to his family — or continue to serve the loyal customer base he amassed over 66 years of work.

Advertise with us

No more was his safety in question than Friday, when two masked men entered his Fifth Avenue shop and stole approximately $300.

According to police, one of the men approached Mr. Montemurro in the front of the store at around 3 p.m. and took money from the cash register. The other man sneaked through the back door.

“He grabbed me from behind and threw me down,” Mr. Montemurro said. “They searched my pockets for money. By the time I got up from the floor, they were gone.” Surveillance video showed one of the men wielding a gun during the robbery, although Mr. Montemurro said he didn’t see it.

“Thank God they didn’t hurt me,” he said. “Money is no problem, money is OK, but if you hurt somebody or kill somebody, that’s a different story.”

Mr. Montemurro, an Italian immigrant, started working as a cobbler in 1949. After moving his business around a few times, he settled in 1999 in New Kensington, where Gene’s Shoe Service has resided ever since.

Advertise with us

There had been “no problems whatsoever” over the next 14 years, he said, but 2014 brought four attempted robberies.

Though his family has urged him to retire for years, the recent crimes have made the idea more of a priority.

His grandson, Bill Wareham, said the family will respect his decision no matter what, but wants him to come home safe from work.

“We love what he does, and that’s something we have told people his entire life,” Mr. Wareham said. “His story is such a unique story of perseverance and prosperity. But as great as the story is, we have to know he’s safe. That’s where the family draws the line.”

Mr. Montemurro said he will “strongly consider” meeting his family’s wishes, but there’s another family he has to consider as well.

Advertise with us

“My business is like one big family,” he said. “I love my customers, and they love me. That’s why they are so loyal.”

As of Tuesday evening, supporters had donated more than $3,300 to “Mr. Gene Montemurro’s appreciation fund” on a popular crowdfunding website. The fund was launched earlier in the week by community members.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1488.