Penn Hills, school board members and administrators are drawing sharp criticism for approving the sale Tuesday of the former Penn Hebron elementary school to the municipality for $250,000.
“With the situation we’re in, I can’t believe this,” said Erin Vecchio, referring to the dire financial circumstance of the school district, which is borrowing to meet its operating costs.
Mrs Vecchio was nominated on both the Democratic and Republican ballots for school board in this month's primary. “Anyone that votes for this is a disgrace. The building was never even put up for sale to see who would buy it.”
Acting Superintendent Nancy Hines said that although the building was never officially listed for sale, the price was appropriate based on the sale of comparable buildings in Allegheny County.
In a report to the school board on April 29, Mrs. Hines listed these school buildings that have been sold since 2011 and the sale prices:
2011 – Gateway sold Pitcairn elementary to Pitcairn for $300,000; Pittsburgh Public Schools sold Overbrook elementary for $150,000 and Vann for $350,000
2012 — Pittsburgh schools sold Northview for $50,000 and Reizenstein Middle for $5.4 million
"Obviously Reizenstein is an unique situation based on its proximity to a rapidly growing commercial site [at Bakery Square]," she wrote.
The Penn Hills district also sold the former Shenandoah elementary school to Redeemer Lutheran Church of Oakmont for $285,000 in 2011.
Mrs. Hines added that informal conversations with local real estate agent Staci Rullo reinforced the idea that the $250,000 price was fair.
“She [Ms. Rullo] stated that abandoned schools are not in high demand and that any interested parties would have come forward, regardless of the fact that this building has not been listed officially for sale,” Mrs. Hines said.
Former school board member Carolyn Faggioli questioned the board’s motive. “It seems odd that right after elections we are giving Penn Hebron [to the municipality] for $250,000 when the charter school offered $500,000,’ she said.
Ms. Faggioli was referring to comments made by Bernice Martin, chairman of the board of trustees for Imagine Entrepreneur charter school. Ms. Martin said that although the charter school had not made a formal offer, they twice asked the school district to enter discussions about selling or leasing the building.
“We are disappointed in the outcome, but are still willing to work with the school district,” said Ms. Martin. “They could have sold the building to us, but it would have been smarter to lease it to us. We would have leased in excess of $500,000 per year.” She said that the charter school will continue to pursue space at the Chambers building on Frankstown Road and estimated the annual lease at approximately $650,000.
The empty school building sits on approximately 20 acres of prime real estate in the heart of the community’s business district on Duff Rd behind Penn Hills shopping center. The property, including the school, has been assessed by Allegheny County at $9.4 million.
The municipality has announced plans to use the site as the home for a new municipal building. Estimates for the new building are in the neighborhood of $10 million to $12 million.
Tim Means, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.
Correction (posted Dec. 4, 2015): In an earlier version of this story, the list of schools sold in 2012 was incorrect.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.