An Allegheny County Common Pleas judge refused Friday to turn over documents related to search warrants executed this week at Plum High School.

Investigators from the county district attorney’s office gathered evidence for three days this week related to the investigation of two teachers accused of having sexual relationships with students. A grand jury also is investigating.

WPXI Inc. motioned Thursday “to intervene and obtain access to the public judicial records,” including a sealing order and search warrant application, both filed Monday. Those documents were not sealed, the petition states.

Public judicial records are filed by a court or used by judges during their decision-making and trigger a presumption of access, said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association.

Advertise with us

The news station’s attorney, Jacqueline Koscelnik, said, “There is simply no basis for WPXI to not have access to them.”

Assistant District Attorney Lisa Mantella argued that as a grand jury is involved, the proceedings need to be secret, and WPXI had “no basis for intervention.”

Judge Jill E. Rangos, who is also supervising the county grand jury investigation, cited “several layers of concern” in denying the request.

She said she was unsure that WPXI had proved the documents were public judicial record, and even if they were, a balancing test could outweigh the right of the public to know. Compelling interests override a public disclosure under the First Amendment, she said.

The judge also cited “additional, specific reasons” that she would not detail during the public hearing.

Advertise with us

WPXI was not seeking sealed material, including the search warrant affidavit, which Judge Rangos “sealed until further order of court.”

If a court has good cause, the definition of which varies from case to case, it can act independently to determine access, Ms. Melewsky said, but added, “If a record isn’t sealed, it’s not sealed.”

After the hearing, Ms. Koscelnik said she was unsure if she would appeal the decision.

Plum superintendent Timothy Glasspool said Wednesday that the district continues to cooperate, providing all materials and equipment outlined in multiple search warrants.

One search warrant, as obtained and released by WTAE-TV, outlined 10 categories of information sought, including student and staff records dating to 2007.

Lexi Belculfine: lbelculfine@post-gazette.com