The former principal of Linton Middle School in the Penn Hills School District who was fired in 2013 is seeking reinstatement.

Davaun Barnett was fired Nov. 25, 2013, and his termination was upheld by the acting secretary of education in July 2014.

Mr. Barnett appealed, and the state Commonwealth Court heard arguments Monday.

Mr. Barnett was fired by the school board for a count of immorality related to $300 that went missing following a school event and what was considered to be misrepresentation by him about it.

Advertise with us

Those actions followed an incident in early May 2013, in which his wife, Lisa Barnett, sought a protection-from-abuse order against him. Mr. Barnett learned of the theft allegations two days after the PFA was obtained.

During Monday’s hearing, Mr. Barnett’s attorney, John Quinn, argued that his client did not have due process in his termination proceedings because he did not know the exact charges against him.

Mr. Barnett believed the charge against him was that he stole the money, and so he prepared his defense against that allegation, Mr. Quinn said.

He later learned that the school district was arguing that Mr. Barnett obfuscated its investigation by lying about the money and its whereabouts — but not that he actually took it.

In addition to the due process claim, Mr. Quinn said the district failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove the immorality count, which requires the district show that the act occurred, that it was offensive to the community, and that it would adversely affect students in the district.

Advertise with us

The district failed to present any evidence for the second and third elements, and the education secretary jumped to those conclusions, Mr. Quinn said.

But Penn Hills School District solicitor Craig Alexander told the three-judge panel that Mr. Barnett’s story changed at every turn, including that his wife had the money, that it was in a different purse of hers and that it had been put in a tin.

Mr. Alexander said that a member of the community actually testified to being offended by Mr. Barnett’s actions, and that every school director on the board lives in the community, as well.

“You’ve still got to prove it,” said Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini.

“He was the one in charge of the event,” Mr. Alexander said.

Advertise with us

Judge Robert Simpson said he was troubled by the case. “It sounds like this fellow was having some personal issues at home,” the judge said.

“I don’t know how I would have found these facts. This doesn’t sound like a way to end somebody’s career on a morality charge.”

Afterward, Mr. Quinn said the board should not have sought termination.

“There could be any kind of incremental discipline,” he said, such as demotion, suspension or administrative leave.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620.