Two Pennsylvania state constables were ordered to stand trial by District Judge Thomas Torkowski after a preliminary hearing Wednesday for an incident in October as they were serving an arrest warrant in Munhall.
Constables Christian Constantini, 25, and Michael Lowman, 45, face charges that they used excessive force when they went to the Timberwood Drive home of Esther Peyton serving a warrant for unpaid parking tickets on Oct. 14.
They each face charges of simple assault and other related charges.
Three people testified during the hearing: Ms. Peyton, 52; her daughter Kimberly Peyton, 22; and Darrel Parker, a detective with the district attorney of Allegheny County.
Esther Peyton said Mr. Constantini forced his way in through the front door and she ran down a short hallway and into her kitchen.
Blaine Jones, who represents Mr. Constantini, asked her why she ran from the constable.
“I was never trying to go anywhere, I was only trying to cooperate,” she said.
She said that she had bruised wrists from being handcuffed too tightly and fractured a bone in her hand when she fell to the ground as the constables tried to remove her from her home.
Mr. Jones also asked if she kicked the constables when she was on the ground. She said no.
Esther Peyon said that Mr. Constantini forced her to the ground. Her daughter, Kimberly Peyton, 22, testified that her mother fell to the ground on her own accord, but added that her view of the situation was obstructed.
The defense attorneys asked the judge to dismiss all charges because they thought Ms. Petyon and her daughter had conflicting stories, but the judge decided to hold the charges for trial.
Neither of the constables spoke during the hearing, but afterwards expressed disappointment with the judge’s decision.
Mike Manko, spokesman for the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office, said that the office intends to file a petition asking for the constables' removal.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.