One of the most heated issues in the final weeks leading to the election of Westmoreland County commissioners involves the business background of one of the candidates.

Opponents of Republican candidate Tyler Courtney, a Greensburg financial adviser who is running with incumbent Republican Commissioner Charles Anderson, have called attention to a 2005 federal court ruling awarding $50,000 in damages for trademark infringement against a company co-owned by Mr. Courtney.

A judge had ruled that a website domain for A1 Mortgage and Financial Services -- A1mortage.com -- caused confusion with a larger and more established company, A1 Mortgage, based in Cranberry.

In previous court action, Mr. Courtney's company had been ordered to include a disclaimer in its advertising that it was not associated with the company in Cranberry.

Advertise with us

The federal judge in 2005 found that Mr. Courtney's testimony in the case was "less than credible" when he denied instructing employees to tell customers that they did not know on which radio stations their company was advertising.

Mr. Courtney denied any wrongdoing.

"The judge's ruling was subjective," he said. "I was simply telling employees not to lie to customers because the radio advertising changed weekly."

Mr. Courtney said he was co-owner of A1 Mortgage and Financial Services from 2002 to 2006 but left before the company declared bankruptcy in late 2006.

Last week, the county Republican committee sought to have a Comcast TV ad by the Democrats on the issue taken off the air, but Comcast attorneys reviewed arguments from both sides and decided the political ad complied with their guidelines.

Advertise with us

"They've been critical of our record," incumbent Democratic Commissioner Ted Kopas said, "so their records are fair game, too." Mr. Kopas is running with Democrat Gerald Lucia, mayor of Mount Pleasant Borough.

Independent Ron Gazze, a Greensburg dentist, is also on the ballot. Of the five candidates, the three who get the most votes will fill the three commissioner seats.

Another point of disagreement between the two sides has been a project labor agreement put in place two years ago by the Democratic majority on the board of commissioners.

It sets forth criteria, such as certified training requirements, that bidders must meet on county construction projects that cost more than $150,000, such as a new district judge's office being built in Export.

The Republicans charge that the agreement requires union labor, raises the cost of construction and leaves out qualified bidders, such as small businesses.

Advertise with us

"I'm not anti-labor, I'm pro-small business," Mr. Anderson said. "I know of a husband and wife who have done work for the county, and they hire workers as needed. They wouldn't qualify under the agreement."

"That work should go to the lowest qualified bidder," Mr. Courtney said. "There are qualified laborers who aren't in unions. And if they aren't qualified, they won't get a performance bond. We have a deficit; we have to watch our spending."

Mr. Kopas and Mr. Lucia disagree.

"That agreement does not say union labor must be used," Mr. Kopas said.

He said when the recent district judge office project was advertised, bids came in under budget.

Advertise with us

"We've built other district judge's offices and this one is coming in at about the same cost," he said, which is about $600,000.

Mr. Kopas said the project will save county taxpayers money in the long run.

"We're trying to get out of the business of renting these district judge offices," he said. "We've found that over the long run, we're spending twice the amount in rent that it would cost to build an office. So it's cheaper to have our own buildings."

All of the candidates agree that fiscal responsibility is the overriding issue facing the county.

The county budget is about $318 million, with $80 million coming from county taxpayers and the rest from the state and federal government.

Advertise with us

This year, the county had to use $11 million from a $33 million surplus to balance the budget.

The Republican candidates maintain the county cannot continue on its path of spending without an eventual tax increase.

But the Democrats say that no tax increase will be needed because of the surplus and budget cutting.

Mr. Lucia said $7 million of this year's deficit was a result of having to pay higher pension costs because of the poor investment returns from the stock market. He said the other $4 million came from higher health care costs for the county's 1,500 employees.

Mr. Gazze, the independent candidate, could not be reached for comment. He has continued to stress he wants voters to elect one Republican, one Democrat and himself so that he could be a buffer between the two political parties.

Advertise with us

He is not accepting contributions and therefore would be unbiased in appointments, he said. He supports term limits for commissioners, limits on campaign contributions and a sales tax in exchange for lower property taxes.

Election director Jim Montini has predicted a low turnout of no more than 30 percent of eligible voters for the non-presidential election, based on a turnout of about 22 percent in this year's primary election.