Sometimes, the fate of Pittsburgh and its sports teams diverge, with athletic success delivering hope and enthusiasm during hard times. This was the case during the 1970s, the decade of the city’s steepest demographic decline, 18.5%, that coincided with the rise of the City of Champions.

And sometimes, eras of optimism for Pittsburgh and its athletes coincide, with on-field success bolstering civic confidence. This was the case during the dozen years from 2005 through 2017, when the Penguins and Steelers racked up five championships and the Pirates thrice poked into the playoffs, all while Pittsburgh became the poster child for Rust Belt recovery.

As the Pirates bring another disappointing season to a close, the Steelers stumble out of the gates and an enigmatic Penguins club suits up, it feels as if the city’s sports are, once again, matching the civic mood and, in so doing, amplifying it.

It’s not a terrible mood, nor is it a very good one. It might be distilled as “here we go again” — a sense of stagnation and repetition, with just enough hope for improvement to keep us invested but an underlying expectation of disappointment. Serious decline feels unlikely, but greatness feels out of reach.

Advertise with us

Perhaps, most of all, there is a sense civically and athletically that those responsible for pursuing greatness don’t have it in them (perhaps exempting Penguins general manager and mayoral doppelganger Kyle Dubas), and that no one in authority is particularly interested in holding them accountable for failing to get there.

Risk management rather than pursuing excellence. Cycles of hope and disappointment while making no real progress.

Worst of all: satisfaction with mediocrity.

Mask off

This was thrown into particularly sharp relief this week, as the Allegheny County courts unsealed a search warrant used to seize documents from the city of Pittsburgh, largely regarding the governance of the Gainey administration.

The slapdash affidavit raised more questions than it answered about the intentions and targets of DA Stephen A. Zappala Jr.’s investigation, gesturing toward broad dysfunction during the Gainey years — covered extensively in this newspaper — without revealing any striking new evidence of legal wrongdoing.

Advertise with us

At least in the short term, the main effect of unsealing the affidavit is to contribute to the public’s frustration with the city’s civic ecosystem: Here we go again.

At a time when peer cities are adapting to the post-COVID and AI-enhanced economy, Pittsburgh is litigating the conduct of the previous mayoral administration. The local conversation is, once again, focused on graft rather than growth.

There are a variety of popular internet memes, typically from Scooby-Doo or professional wrestling, that go like this: A person removes a mask, only to reveal the same face underneath. Change in Pittsburgh too often seems superficial, with all the same dysfunction remaining the order of the day.

Choosing risk

If that sounds familiar, well, it should. It’s certainly the impression Mike McCarthy’s Steelers have given through two weeks of the new NFL season, and the story of a generation of Pirates baseball. The hockey team is on a different trajectory — but the idea of an old club trying to muster one last unlikely run at glory hits a little close to home, too.

The underlying question that pervades Pittsburgh is whether excellence, athletic or economic, is really what those in leadership want. Certainly, they want it in the abstract, but that doesn’t suffice.

Advertise with us

Are they willing to do what it takes to achieve it?

Are they willing to ruffle feathers in their organizations and the wider ecosystem? Are they willing to make changes that might reflect badly on their predecessors or highlight stagnation elsewhere? Are they willing to invest their money and reputations in bold strategies — whether that’s paying for free-agent sluggers or making corporate investments in local economic development?

All these questions have one thing in common: They describe taking calculated risks.

Tolerating mediocrity

I’ve come to believe that risk management — which in this case is a euphemism for risk avoidance — may be the signal feature of Pittsburgh’s civic culture. The history and sociology behind this deserves a column of its own, but in its simplest form it’s a residue of the collapse of heavy industry, which left behind a culture that valued stability.

That’s fine as far as it goes — we can’t wish away our history and shouldn’t try to — but it becomes a problem when it’s so pervasive that stability smothers every other civic goal. That becomes a culture that seeps into individual leaders, teaching them that boldness is punished while mediocrity is safe.

Advertise with us

So I think the mood in Pittsburgh is perhaps more sour than strictly indicated by economic-demographic data because it seems that the city’s risk-averse, safety-first sensibility now also controls the one system that’s supposed to be defined by courage and dash: our sports teams.

What has been a source of energy and verve, in contrast with the city’s general sleepiness, now only contributes to a pervasive feeling of stagnation and mediocrity.

Worse still, those in leadership seem to be much more tolerant of this state of affairs than everyday people, leaving us feeling stuck with their lowered standards. As if Pittsburgh doesn’t deserve better.

But it does. An athletic renaissance may not lead directly to a civic one, but a spark of life — a spark of courage and boldness and excitement — on the field might just remind the city what it’s missing from its civic leadership.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Here’s one way Pittsburgh is beating Silicon Valley.”