Whatever the demographers say, I believe the line between millennials and Gen Z is whether or not you have a working memory of Sept. 11, 2001.
While so much has happened since, 9/11 remains the fulcrum of the modern world. To some degree or another, just about every major political event since can trace its lineage to that Tuesday, and it is impossible to understand the present moment without making those connections.
Yet for my children and almost everyone under 30 years old, 9/11 belongs in the category of history, rather than memory. Study, rather than experience.
There’s no stopping this process. It’s the fate of every great event — every war, every tragedy, every triumph — and it’s the fate of every generation to watch it happen.
Another piece of history
There’s a kids’ graphic novel series called “I Survived.” Each book tells the story of a child who lives to tell the tale of some historic cataclysm: the destruction of Pompeii, the Great Chicago Fire, Pearl Harbor. My kids love them, even the young ones that don’t yet read well.
One day I saw lying around the house “I Survived: The Attacks of September 11, 2001.” On the cover is a boy in a gray hoodie on a New York street looking up at the burning towers. I didn’t like it: It felt at once too heavy for kids and too trivial a depiction of such a traumatic event. This wasn’t some distant abstraction suitable as a backdrop for children’s drama: I saw the towers burning on television.
Read More
But my children didn’t. For them, 9/11 is just as much a historical event as Gettysburg, the Titanic and (yes) Hurricane Katrina — all “I Survived” titles. So I decided this was as good a way as any to introduce them to the topic, and I made it clear I could talk with them about it if they wanted. After all, I lived through it.
This is something the younger ones in particular find amazing. Sept. 11 is part of the past, so of course Grandma and Grandpa know all about it, but Mom and Dad are part of the present. It doesn’t compute that we lived through history.
And it’s hard for me to accept that’s what it’s becoming.
Keeping memory alive
That’s why, this summer, we took our family to the Flight 93 National Memorial in Somerset County.
The purpose of any memorial is, firstly, to honor the dead. But in so doing, it serves another essential social purpose: slowing the passage of important events — particularly examples of evildoing and heroism that should inform and inspire for generations to come — from experience to memory to history.
In this, the Flight 93 memorial succeeds tremendously.
The site itself is much more dramatic than I expected, with the visitor center and museum on a hilltop overlooking the expansive grounds. The slate-black walkway that follows the flightpath immediately immerses you in the story and meaning of the place. The semicircular “allée,” which sweeps around the site for over a mile and offers expansive views, gives the memorial a scale appropriate to the heroism it commemorates.
I told the kids to treat the entire site as if it were a cemetery, applying the usual rules of decorum. I can’t say they complied perfectly, but the design facilitated a sense of wonder and solemnity and appreciation that made it easier — especially at the Memorial Plaza, where the site of the crash itself is set off by marble blocks bearing the names of the hero-victims.
The museum, meanwhile, restored my own memories that had faded, and corrected one serious misapprehension: I had thought Flight 93 was about to be shot down when it was crashed. But the order came down much later — likely too late to prevent the possible destruction of the U.S. Capitol.
The only feature I kept the children from experiencing was the collection of recordings of phone calls made by passengers to their loved ones. That seemed an emotional weight they were not yet prepared to bear.
Touchpoint with reality
The 25th year since the attacks marks roughly a generation since everything changed. Another 25 years hence, another generation will have encountered 9/11 as history rather than memory.
There is no way to stop this passage of events — from real to abstraction, from formative experience to object of curiosity and study (and revisionism). We need only regard the rise of antisemitism, as the Holocaust makes that journey despite every effort to stop it, to prove this inexorability.
There is no way to make my children’s relationship to 9/11 the same as my own. And it’s not right to try. The task of parents and teachers and other authorities is to help young people make sense of the near past and how it has formed the present, not to bring it into the present.
Yet we can ensure that the story younger generations receive about that day and its antecedents and aftermath is honest and complete and humane. We can talk with them about our own experiences, rather than letting them rely on the online fever swamps. We can accentuate the heroism rather than the terror.
And, perhaps above all, we can visit the sites themselves, where the mists of history briefly part and the generations can share a touchpoint with the reality of Sept. 11, 2001.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Post-Gazette listening tour will give Pittsburghers the mic.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.