The only two times I’ve seen Gov. Josh Shapiro in the flesh, he was extolling AI and data centers as critical to Pennsylvania’s — and in particular Pittsburgh’s — economic future. First it was at the inaugural AI Horizons conference in 2024 in Bakery Square, then it was at U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick’s Pennsylvania Energy and Innovation Summit last summer at CMU.

Now he condemns data center developers as “bullies” and “speculators,” while touting his executive action this week as the “strictest guardrails in the nation.”

Did the reality on the ground change, or just the politics?

Pragmatism vs. populism

Shapiro’s shift from his instinctive pragmatism to an awkward populism on this issue partially reflects the reality of the data center proliferation: There is land speculation occurring, and some developers are trying to bully local communities into submission, including by having public officials sign non-disclosure agreements that bind them from communicating with their constituents.

Advertise with us

But the extent of the governor’s transformation in rhetoric and policy also reflects the fastest cross-partisan lurch in public opinion in recent memory, one that is connected at least as much to fearmongering and misinformation, particularly regarding data centers’ environmental effects, as it is to experience and reality.

A majority of members of both parties are now opposed to data center construction near them — 69% of Democrats and 54% of Republicans — according to a recent poll by the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania. Only a year ago, people outside data center hotspots like northern Virginia were generally ignorant of or indifferent to the issue.

This raises a critical question about the nature of political leadership: Are elected officials to follow the people regardless of where the people go, or are they to exercise their own informed judgment about what is best for the political community for which they are responsible?

Striking a balance

It’s clear where Shapiro’s informed judgment lied, at least until recently: AI and data centers are here to stay, and Pennsylvania would be foolish not to try to lead in this area. This has been his consistent message for years. It is also my own judgment, despite my philosophical and aesthetic distaste for AI and data centers.

The popular governor does not face a credible threat to his re-election this November — polls consistently show Shapiro with a double-digit lead over Republican State Treasurer Stacy Garrity — and so he should have the political freedom to chart a moderately pro-data center course. This would recognize the facilities’ economic value and national security importance, while ensuring that energy supplies remain adequate and that so-called hyperscalers don’t steamroll communities.

Advertise with us

Indeed, this is basically what Shapiro articulated in this February’s budget address, when he said that Pennsylvania is “well-positioned to play a leading role” in America’s “battle for AI supremacy against China” while touting a $20 billion data-center investment by Amazon. But he also announced his Governor’s Responsible Infrastructure Development (GRID) standards to “hold data center developers accountable.”

GRID includes four criteria: 1) Data center developers have to produce or pay for at least as much new power as their facilities would guzzle; 2) they must be candid with local communities about their plans; 3) they need to enter into community benefits agreements (CBAs), particularly regarding hiring local workers; and 4) they have to meet high environmental standards, including water conservation.

The first and second standards are critical. The third is fine, so long as the CBAs actually benefit the communities in question, and not just interest groups seeking payouts. The last is a red herring: Concerns about data-center water consumption are overblown, especially in water-rich regions like Pennsylvania.

On the whole, though, it seemed Shapiro had successfully leavened his recognition of data centers’ potential with respect for popular concerns about them.

Pennsylvania vs. presidency

This week, however, both in rhetoric and regulation Shapiro made Pennsylvania actively hostile to data centers.

Advertise with us

He imposed the GRID standards as strict requirements (“strictest…in the nation”) while kicking data center projects off the state’s Fast Track permitting program. This makes state permits contingent on criteria beyond the scope of the permit, such as signing CBAs, giving interest groups enormous leverage. Data centers now have to swim against the current in the state’s already treacherous permitting waters.

This may be what a majority of both parties (and Independents) want to hear, but it’s not what’s right for Pennsylvania. And it’s not what Shapiro claimed to believe was best for Pennsylvania until, well, just now.

It’s certainly possible the governor has become aware of new sins committed by data center developers that radically changed his view. Leaders are allowed to change their minds — in fact, they should when they get new information.

It’s also the case that Shapiro’s new data center rules weren’t dashed off: They’re constructed to leave space for some development, as opposed to flat moratoria proposed and imposed elsewhere.

But on the whole Pennsylvania has now ceded its competitive advantage, while its governor has taken one of the most hostile rhetorical postures in the nation. It’s hard to avoid the conclusion Shapiro’s instincts for pragmatic governance are being distorted by his presidential ambitions — which require a significant demonstration of strength in this November’s election.

Advertise with us

Indeed, on Thursday I was filling in at KDKA radio when a Shapiro for Governor ad hit the airwaves. It was slamming Stacy Garrity for being soft on data centers.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “The assessment man cometh.”