I remember, just barely, the period of blessed innocence before I became educated about the nature of property assessment and taxation in Allegheny County. When I only had a vague sense that reassessments were scary (for homeowners, but particularly for politicians) and the system was arcane. When my life was happy and carefree.
But I have since been initiated into the terrible mysteries — not completely, but enough to understand how it violates nearly every rule of good governance, how it strangles in particular the county’s down-and-out communities, how it creates unnecessary uncertainty for both taxpayers (how much we’ll pay) and taxing bodies (how much they’ll get).
This week, the county likely began its roughly quindecennial process of reassessing about 600,000 real estate parcels. To highlight how absurd it all is, the order to do so wasn’t signed by anyone with actual responsibility for Allegheny County, but by a judge from Armstrong County. Because no one here with the power to do the right thing could be trusted to do it.
Which shows that the system, here and across Pennsylvania, is in need of reforms deeper than anything one judge can effect.
Tax revolt
To recap, Judge Kenneth Valasek’s decision was prompted by a suit brought by Churchill homeowner Flavia Laun, who contended that the county’s property tax system violated the state constitution’s requirement of “uniformity” in taxation. Which it facially does.
The Laun home’s assessed value was appealed upon purchase — the so-called “newcomer’s tax” — because the sale price was much higher than the 2012 assessment. This knocked her effective tax rate out of whack with her neighbors’.
As the former Post-Gazette Editorial Board discussed in years past, it’s easy to find similar properties on the same block, especially in high-demand neighborhoods like Lawrenceville, with assessed values several hundred thousand dollars apart — leading to annual tax bills tens of thousands of dollars apart.
Laun’s case was handled by Ira Weiss, solicitor for Pittsburgh Public Schools as well as several other county school districts, which lose out most in the current system. This is not because reassessments are broad-based tax hikes — the state’s anti-windfall provisions require tax rates to be adjusted downward in line with assessment hikes — but because regular assessments provide greater certainty in the revenues schools entirely depend on.
Judge Valasek’s order gives the county a nine-month buffer to secure a third-party contractor and begin the reassessment process, and gives a too-generous deadline of 2032 for the new values to go into effect. Importantly — in a reflection of the perverse political incentives of reassessment in Allegheny County — he requires the appointment of a “special master,” or independent expert, to oversee the process.
Stretched to Armstrong
This outcome could not have been better for County Executive Sara Innamorato if she had scripted it herself. She immediately announced she would comply with the judge’s order, which achieves an outcome she initially campaigned on while relieving her of the duty of (and political responsibility for) making the call herself.
Notably, her quick cooperation stands in contrast to former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, who went to war with Allegheny County Judge R. Stanton Wettick on this issue.
Further in Innamorato’s favor, the order’s July 2027 deadline for substantially commencing the reassessment is beyond next year’s primary election. And it’s all but impossible any upsetting results of the process will have been released to property owners before the general election (on the off-chance she has a serious Republican challenger).
Innamorato’s strategy to wait for the court to render a definitive judgment has been richly rewarded — even if the delay has caused the property tax base across the county to further deteriorate.
Last of its kind
More importantly, though, the fact it came to this — and, in particular, the fact Allegheny County authorities kicked the final decision out of the county — testifies to how broken the county’s assessment system is.
Property taxes are the foundation of local and county government finances, and there’s no chance that will change. That means that assessing properties is a core government responsibility, one that underlies all other public services.
If Allegheny County officials cannot be trusted to fulfill this responsibility, which this process proves they cannot be, then it must be taken from them. This is why Judge Valasek opined from the bench that the county should mandate regular assessments, and why the county’s decennial Government Review Commission released similar guidance, in anticipation of its final report.
This should be — this must be — the last time a judge orders a reassessment in Allegheny County. County Council must pass regular reassessments, and the state legislature must take up Sen. Wayne Fontana’s bill to bring Pennsylvania in line with every other state in the union.
It cannot be emphasized enough that Pennsylvania’s ad hoc assessments are unique. This means, because Philadelphia reassesses every three years, that Allegheny County is by far the most populous county in America without regular assessments. Residents of other states — rightly! — regard our system as ludicrous.
It should not have come to this once again. Innamorato should have done the right thing herself. But it would have been politically ruinous, and so there was never a chance it would happen.
Which is exactly why reassessments must be placed on the schedule and beyond politics.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Everyday magic.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.