My older kids’ favorite scene in the 2010 Christopher Nolan dream-based film “Inception” is when Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s character is trying, unsuccessfully, to deal with snipers by using an assault rifle. Suddenly Tom Hardy appears in the frame saying, in his perfectly relaxed British English, “You mustn’t be afraid to dream a little bigger, darling.” He then reveals a grenade launcher and blows the assailants to smithereens.

This is basically how I feel about the stretch of State Route 65, or Ohio River Boulevard, that divides Manchester from Chateau between the Norfolk Southern railroad tracks and the West End Bridge. Sure, there are gentle interventions that can alleviate some of the damage caused by this highway to neighboring communities.

But ultimately we mustn’t be afraid to dream a little bigger, and blow it to smithereens.

Atonement for sins

The City of Pittsburgh is taking the first baby steps toward that goal. In little-noticed social media postings last week, the Department of City Planning announced the first public meeting regarding a “feasibility study” — humorously called “Manchester Reunited” — to consider the future of this corridor. The event will occur this Wednesday at 6 p.m. at the Manchester Citizens Corporation on Allegheny Avenue.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh has more than its share of urban highway sins. But what Route 65 did to Manchester and Chateau was the most egregious and unnecessary, while fixing it is the most realistic.

The city features on its website for the study a historic image of the Ohio riverfront with an intact urban fabric: The neighborhoods are knitted together with a street grid, with seamless transitions among residential, commercial and light industrial uses, including access to the river.

Then there’s a photo of the area after the 1970s construction of Route 65. The highway is a concrete gash that required razing at least 13 city blocks for the road itself. Worse, for much of its length the “boulevard” is buttressed by walls up to 40 feet high, which visually and practically cut off Manchester from Chateau and the riverfront.

Now their land uses are entirely distinct. Manchester has suffered from being nearly completely hemmed in by roadways and railways, which serve the people of that neighborhood very little. Chateau’s residential population, meanwhile, is estimated around the single digits (Census estimates are uncertain at such low figures).

I have no idea where those residences are.

Advertise with us

The Esplanade opportunity

Soon, however, there will be very visible residences in Chateau, and a statistically significant number of people living there. The Piatt Companies’ Esplanade development, along the Ohio west of the West End Bridge, will bring over 400 housing units, a hotel, restaurants, offices and, of course, a Ferris wheel.

Understandably, given the history of how big construction with big promises have ended for Manchester-Chateau, there is skepticism, as documented by the Post-Gazette’s Sono Motoyama this weekend. Will this, like the highway, mostly benefit others and leave the neighbors behind? Or maybe even leave them worse off, with skyrocketing rents but few public realm improvements to match them?

But allow me to offer some realistic optimism: Esplanade is the best chance yet to deal with the Route 65 problem.

Precisely because of the damage the highway has done to Manchester and Chateau, the case for spending tens and probably hundreds of millions to knit them back together was weak. I don’t think Manchester residents have been clamoring to be able to walk to the limo lots or the strip club in Chateau.

Esplanade changes the game: There will soon be a major destination on the river side of Route 65, which throws into much sharper relief the damage the concrete gash does to Manchester. Further, the developers themselves are incentivized to fix Ohio River Boulevard because it’s ugly and because it — along with the one-way streets that flank it — inhibits access to the property.

Advertise with us

Indeed the Piatt Companies and the people of Manchester could and should form a united front on this point.

Dreaming bigger

So, what are the actual options for Route 65?

My preference, as I already indicated, is to blow it up. Replace it with a multi-modal at-grade boulevard, with a tree canopy and ample bike and pedestrian infrastructure.

Don’t worry about the traffic: PennDOT’s 2025 traffic data estimates 20,000 cars use that stretch of highway daily, which is half of at-grade Route 51 from the suburbs to the Liberty Bridge. In fact, it’s even less than the Oakland stretch of Boulevard of the Allies and Bates Street.

The 2019 Manchester-Chateau Neighborhood Plan expresses some skepticism of this solution, because the road must be elevated to clear the railroad tracks to the north and to connect with the West End Bridge to the south. The at-grade portion might be limited to a few blocks.

Advertise with us

The alternative would be to keep Route 65 elevated but transform it into an attractive bridge, with as much air beneath as possible — no more 40-foot concrete walls. This would alleviate the visual barrier and allow for significant multi-modal crossings between the pylons.

No matter the highway solution, for the good of both Esplanade and the neighborhoods, leaving space to extend the T up the Ohio must be part of the package.

Whether any of this comes to pass will depend, of course, on state and federal funding that’s speculative at best. But for now, as the city just focuses on “feasibility,” we all mustn’t be afraid to dream a little bigger.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Beyond abundance: One surprising way Pittsburgh may be poised for the future.”