It was a perfectly Pittsburgh evening at PNC Park: the sun had tucked behind the first-base grandstand; the skyline was lighting up; and the Pirates were floundering against the Diamondbacks. There’s no better time or place for a big conversation.

“Where do you think AI is taking the world?” I asked my new acquaintance, a friend of a friend and the founder of a tech company. “There’s a good chance it will unlock abundance like human beings have never seen before,” he said. “But — we’ll be more miserable than ever.”

I’m more confident about the shared despair than the shared abundance. But, on the whole, I think he was exactly right.

And the people and communities who fare best will be those rooted in something beyond material goods.

Advertise with us

Rich but poor

You can see it right now. In terms of the raw amount and availability of resources — not just high technology but nutritious food, extensive shelter, an extraordinary array of consumer choices — Americans today are better off than any people in world history.

Yet perceptions of “the economy” are stubbornly poor (and increasingly partisan) while trust in institutions has cratered.

More alarming still, suicide rates are at or near historic highs. Overdose deaths — another form of “deaths of despair” — have declined in recent years, but addiction remains a social scourge. And not just to drugs but to gambling, with some estimates reaching 10% of young men showing signs of problem sports betting.

Modern Americans’ mental health is also notoriously poor, with up to one in six taking daily medications to manage their condition. This obviously doesn’t count the use of illegal substances for the same purpose.

Then there’s birth rates, the premier measure of broad hope in the future of American society and human civilization, which have plummeted to well below replacement over the past two decades.

Advertise with us

The materialist explanation, favored by the political left, is that this is mostly if not entirely a problem of the distribution of resources: If more people had greater access to our shared bounty, the anxiety induced by precarity and visible inequality would dissipate.

There’s undoubtedly an element of truth in this. It’s well-established on the individual level that access to money and self-reported happiness correlate, at least up to a plateau of financial stability.

The research is also clear, however, that money is only one determinant of happiness. Further, on the social level there’s no neat correlation between measures of hope and the policies of U.S. states. This also applies internationally where, if anything, the people of poorer nations demonstrate greater degrees of hope for themselves and the future.

Something else is going on.

AI alienation

Let’s stipulate my conversation partner’s prediction about AI: that it will unleash abundance far beyond what we currently experience. Economic growth will be supercharged. Many forms of work will fade away. Life will be, in material terms, easier than ever.

Advertise with us

But if today’s comparative abundance hasn’t led to more hope and happiness and contentment but to more anxiety and despair and dysregulation, why should we expect the next level to produce the opposite effect?

First of all, AI’s disruptions to work and earning will undoubtedly increase (at least initially) actual and felt inequality, enhancing social tensions and bolstering the left’s case for a corrective intervention.

The deeper problem, however, is how technology has progressively alienated people from each other, from sources of meaning, and even from reality itself. Material abundance may help some people cope with this, but for others it further highlights and exacerbates their sense of purposelessness. This will be all the worse, of course, for those who feel they deserve greater access to abundance than they enjoy — a sentiment, whether fair or unfair, that is easily exploited by demagogues.

Under these conditions — high wealth, high inequality, low trust, low meaning — the tech giants’ AI utopia quickly becomes the reverse.

Hope in place

I don’t yet have a political answer to this state of affairs. Attempts by politicians and the state to generate meaning and connectedness are doomed to become either irrelevant or grotesque abuses.

Advertise with us

I do, however, have an observation that has political consequences: The people, families and communities who are able to thrive under these conditions will share rootedness in something beyond technology and beyond material abundance.

The clearest example of this is religion. As it stands, on all the measures listed above and many more, those rooted in a supernatural sense of their purpose fare better. As the visible world proves more and more insufficient, being anchored in supernatural hope becomes more and more valuable.

Faith, though, isn’t the only anchor (even if I believe it’s the surest). Too often ignored is the way rootedness in a place can mitigate the anxieties of an abundant but meaningless world.

To be committed to a place, and to the people and communities who call it home, instills a sense of responsibility for the future that works against despair. An important Pittsburgh proviso: It’s important that this connection to place not be entirely focused on the past — that is, nostalgia — which always produces disappointment. It must include respect for the past along with a commitment to preserve and expand what is good for the future.

Whatever AI brings, real places will become increasingly attractive and valuable. Places that have strong cultures and senses of themselves. Places where human-scale communities — neighborhoods — exist and thrive. Places where you feel connected to other people and to institutions and to parks and streets and trails and vistas.

Advertise with us

Places where you can imagine building not just a life but a family and a legacy whose meaning goes beyond any wealth or power technology can generate.

Places like Pittsburgh.

Maybe this city will become a global AI hub, maybe it won’t. But it’s places like Pittsburgh that will be oases of reality and humanity in an increasingly artificial world.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Allegheny County pension plan suffers from too many cooks.”