The final days of the Grandview United Presbyterian Church, which in varied forms has stood on the same site since the mid-1800s, are fast approaching.
A massive blaze on July 7 tore through the landmark structure, which has existed in its basic current form since 1891, with smoke along Mount Washington’s scenic Grandview Avenue visible for miles — including by spectators catching an evening matchup at PNC Park between the Pirates and Atlanta Braves.
Investigators still are working to determine what caused the 3-alarm blaze that took more than three hours to bring under control on a hot and humid summer day.
After the flames were extinguished, only a hulking shell of the church remained — its roof partially collapsed, the brick facade crumbled and its stained glass windows in ruins.
The fire investigation is continuing, said Cara Cruz, a city public information officer. No one has been charged in connection with the fire, although a man at the site was charged with obstructing emergency services, among other things.
A demolition order dated July 8 has been posted on the church, ordering its destruction to take place by July 20.
Read More
Since receiving the emergency demolition order, the Pittsburgh Presbytery, which owns the church, has been working closely with the city’s code enforcement office to schedule the demolition, according to an email from the Presbytery.
The organization has retained Schaaf Excavating Contractors to demolish the building as soon as a permit is approved the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections. The permit application was submitted July 17.
“We are deeply saddened by the loss of this historic building and are grateful for the response of fire and all emergency personnel,” a statement from the Pittsburgh Presbytery said. “We also recognize the disruption this incident has caused for neighbors and the surrounding community, and we appreciate their patience as this process moves forward.”
For Mike Carlin, executive director of the Mount Washington Community Development Corp., the demolition can’t come soon enough.
“I would say, the sooner, the better. It’s an accident waiting to happen,” he said. The last thing anyone wants is to see a curious child or someone scrounging for scrap metal to get hurt, he said.
“It’s wide open. You can just stroll in there,” Carlin said.
There are concrete barricades to block traffic next to the structure and signs are posted warning pedestrians and curious onlookers to steer clear.
Next door to the church, the Carnegie Library has been closed since the fire and plans to remain so until at least July 22, according to a notice on its website.
From humble beginnings
Community members first gathered to worship and hold Sunday school classes in a 2-story log structure on the church’s current site beginning in 1851, while Millard Filmore served as the nation’s 13th president. Thirty-one additional men have served as president since then.
The Grandview United Presbyterian Church was organized on June 30, 1857, as the Mount Washington Presbyterian Church, with its name changing to Grandview in 1961, according to Jessica McClure Archer, a general minister at the Pittsburgh Presbytery, who shared the church’s history in an email.
The organization of the congregation and building of the first church came in 1859, Archer said.
The structure in its current basic form was constructed around 1891. The portion of the building encompassing parlors on the main level and gym and Sunday School rooms beneath was added in 1912.
The first manse was added to the structure in 1903, and the second and current manse erected in 1938.
The brick veneer was added in 1948 along with other improvements. In the last substantial construction before the church closed on New Year’s Eve 2022, the sanctuary was renovated in both 1953 and 1964.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.