Pittsburgh has been known as a cradle of industrialists, of quarterbacks and of robots. But for a period of several years beginning about a decade ago, it also became a nursery for left-wing politicos.

Several of the progressive candidates who burst onto the scene in those years have become fixtures in Western Pennsylvania politics, including Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato and U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, both of whom won state House races in 2018 as seemingly long-shot Democratic Socialists of America-endorsed challengers against established Democratic office holders. The next year, Bethany Hallam seized the at-large County Council seat she has held ever since.

Yet among the most notable, and now notorious, person to emerge from that scene wasn’t a candidate or official, but a strategist and consultant. It was a young man who showed up in Pittsburgh from the East Coast at just the right time to test his theories of left-wing electioneering in a political laboratory small enough where he could really make a difference, and big enough where his work could be noticed.

His name is Daniel Moraff, and he was one of the strategists who recruited and vetted Graham Platner, the doomed candidate for U.S. senator from Maine.

Advertise with us

Moraff in Maine

It would be tempting to argue that the deficits that led to the Platner mess were obvious when Moraff cut his teeth here, but the data doesn’t back that up.

While Pittsburgh’s left-wing activists have taken to social media to distance themselves from Moraff, including several implying that he was essentially run out of town, most also acknowledge — rightly, I think — that his theories of electoral politics in the 21st century weren’t the problem.

To review, Platner was scooped out of obscurity as an oysterman and small-town activist by Moraff, his partner Leanne Fan and left-wing operative Morris Katz. The goal was to secure the endorsement of U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders, own the progressive lane in the Democratic primary for U.S. Senate, overwhelm the pick of establishment Democrats (incumbent Gov. Janet Mills) and sweep away longtime Republican Sen. Susan Collins.

The first three steps worked perfectly, completely validating Platner’s handlers’ theory of the case (more on that later). But the foundation of Platner’s candidacy was slowly eroded by a drip of scandals, culminating in a credible claim of sexual assault that finally swept him away.

Progressive mastermind

Moraff, in particular, has come under public scrutiny for an interview he granted to the Wall Street Journal last month. In this videotaped conversation, he described — with a level of insouciance that appears, in retrospect, extremely hubristic — how his team paid for a brief vetting of Platner that failed to uncover many of the flaws that eventually sank him, including his Nazi Totenkopf tattoo and his disparaging remarks about, and alleged abusive behavior toward, women.

Advertise with us

The operative brushed off these concerns with a laugh, saying, “Part of our thesis here is that people do not want their candidates grown in vats. They want people who are real human beings, and they want people who do not look and sound like the back-room people who’ve been leading this country off a cliff for the last century. And that was Graham.”

Until that very last sentence, Moraff’s answer is entirely correct. And I suspect he learned it, or at least demonstrated it, right here in Pittsburgh.

He was there at the beginning, running the 2017 independent/DSA campaign of magistrate candidate Mik Pappas, who knocked off 24-year incumbent Ron Costa Sr. in the East End. He then plucked Summer Lee out of Mon Valley community organizing and ran her smashingly successful 2018 primary campaign — a 45-point victory — against incumbent state Rep. Paul Costa. He was still on the scene during Hallam’s 2019 bid.

Everything he touched turned to electoral gold, and he parlayed that success and confidence into a national profile. What went wrong in Maine?

Political reality

It wasn’t that the lessons of Pittsburgh were wrong. It was that he had forgotten what they actually were.

Advertise with us

Let’s focus on Lee, now among the most powerful forces in the region’s politics. She was not “grown in a vat,” to use Moraff’s excellent phrase to describe politicians with picture-perfect resumes and screen tests. She’s a “real human being” with a personality — along with visible rough edges — that recognizably belongs to a real person. Her passion stems from experience. Whatever you think of her ideological commitments, no one would dare claim they were contrived.

As I wrote more than three years ago, “With Summer Lee, everything is real.”

The problem with Platner is that Moraff knew, or absolutely should have known, that he was not the person the campaign claimed. Or, more accurately, the person the campaign invented.

The lesson of Pittsburgh was that if you find and run real people with real stories and real communication skills — not classroom-taught skills, but natural charisma — voters will respond positively.

In Maine, Moraff took a person who looked authentic, then invented an “authentic” persona and backstory to match. The real Graham Platner is the failed scion of a wealthy coastal Maine family who gathered oysters for his mother’s fancy restaurant.

Advertise with us

Even if the rape allegation had never come to light, Platner eventually would have been undone by the disconnect between image and reality. Moraff’s hubris was in thinking he was good enough that he no longer needed the right person, as he did in Pittsburgh: He could just create one.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Finding hope for America's future in Friendship (the neighborhood).”