My conversation partner, a longtime Virginian, made the mistake of asking how local governance in Western Pennsylvania compares with the Old Dominion. By the time I was done — he was exceptionally patient — it was clear he was glad to have settled around Richmond, not Pittsburgh.
I’m not certain the phrase “but that doesn’t make any sense!” was actually uttered, but it was clearly communicated very politely in the Virginia way, with the countenance alone.
My family was visiting my wife’s parents near Richmond for Independence Day, as has become tradition. Over the years, I have been forced to admit that one of Pennsylvania’s sister commonwealths has some lessons to teach us.
Indeed, talking with someone not from here is one of the best ways to be reminded of just how unusual Pittsburgh is. Sure, sometimes we overstate our distinctiveness — there are, in fact, other sports-mad cities with strong neighborhoods and manufacturing legacies — but in many respects, from the Appalachian geography to the political culture, Pittsburgh really is very different.
Much of that weirdness is good, and we shouldn’t be ashamed of it. But some of it, well, just doesn’t make sense. And there are lessons to learn from places that do things differently.
Fragmentation vs. simplicity
The chat began with my in-laws’ friend, who had generously shared his pool with my crazy kids during the heat wave, asking me how counties and cities work in the Keystone State. It was like handing a very juicy bone to a very hungry Rottweiler.
I explained how, up here, every square inch of land is part of a city, township or borough (and in one case — Bloomsburg, Columbia County — a town) in addition to a county. Therefore every Pennsylvanian is subject to three levels of government under state law. There is no “unincorporated land” — that is, places subject directly to a county government, with no local jurisdiction in between.
One consequence — in a region as geographically and demographically splintered as Western Pennsylvania — is governmental fragmentation. Allegheny County’s 130 municipalities is a notoriously large number.
It’s very important for Pittsburghers to realize that this is not normal.
Significant tracts of unincorporated land — along with many services being rendered at the county level — are the norm around the country.
Virginia is actually unusual in the other direction: toward governmental simplicity. In the Old Dominion, every square inch is part of a county or an independent city: no boroughs or townships. For most residents, there are only two levels of government.
Virginia has 522 governmental units. Compare that to Pennsylvania’s 4,851.
There are drawbacks to Virginia’s system, most notably the lack of local responsiveness.
If you have a nasty pothole in Henrico County, population 343,000, which surrounds Richmond on three sides, your one recourse is to call the county — no hyperlocal council members or public works chiefs to hassle in the Giant Eagle parking lot.
Yet it has become clear to the point of self-evident for me that, on the whole, simpler systems produce more efficient governance.
Complaints vs. solutions
The conversation turned to taxation, which further blew my interlocutor’s Virginian mind.
You see, I said, it’s impossible to compare property tax rates across Keystone State counties because they’re all working with assessed values from different years — some that were set decades or even generations ago.
On paper, Cranberry Township’s 15.75 mills appears exorbitant next to Marshall Township’s 1.42 mills, but because Butler County hasn’t reassessed since 1969(!), who can say?
Here’s how property reassessments work in Virginia: The state requires that each city reassess at least every four years and each county at least every six years. According to a 2024 paper from the Virginia Cooperative Extension, nearly half of the commonwealth’s independent cities reassess annually, while counties typically opt for periods of four to six years, particularly in the more sparsely populated western and southern regions.
This system respects the distinctive needs of the cities and counties of a diverse state, and may provide a model for Pennsylvania, where small-county representatives have stridently opposed attempts to impose regular assessments.
This eliminates the problem that has long beset Allegheny County, where its needs as a dense county with a dynamic real estate market are undercut by the strong political disincentive to call reassessments. This hurts the county as a whole and every municipality and school district within it.
Lessons from the Old Dominion
It doesn’t come naturally to me to hold out other places as models for my hometown — and Virginia, in particular, is historically a bit self-satisfied for my taste.
Yet there’s no denying not just its demographic and economic growth, but its visible quality. I hate to admit it, but driving from southwestern Pennsylvania to Virginia is like traveling from a second- to a first-world country.
To figure out how to make Pittsburgh better, you have to bring some notes home from elsewhere.
When it comes to culture, Pittsburgh’s weirdness is one of its greatest assets. When it comes to governance — my Virginian friend’s astonishment said it all.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “America, the beautiful story.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.