When then-U.S. Sen. JD Vance accepted the vice-presidential nomination at the 2024 Republican National Convention, he said all the things you’d expect a man who’d pledged his fealty to Donald Trump to say. But because Vance is, unusually in today’s politics, also a man who values ideas, he sneaked a few big ones in there.

The biggest of all came near the end, when he described the “cemetery plot on a mountainside in Eastern Kentucky” where “seven generations of people who have fought for this country” are buried, and where “my children will lay me to rest.” He continued:

“Now that’s not just an idea, my friends. That’s not just a set of principles. Even though the ideas and the principles are great, that is a homeland. That is our homeland. People will not fight for abstractions, but they will fight for their home.”

This was the most direct assault I’d ever heard from a major politician on a bedrock assumption of American self-identity: the concept that America is, uniquely in world history, first and foremost an idea. Many commentators deplored this maneuver, accusing Vance of embracing a “blood and soil” concept of America more suited to European ethno-nationalism, even fascism.

Advertise with us

On the occasion of America’s 250th birthday, however, I’d like to propose that on the narrow point that America is and must be more than an idea, Vance is right. In fact, I think a renewal of American pride and patriotism depends on it.

Loss of confidence

Comparing the enthusiasm for America’s quarter-millennium milestone with previous 50-year anniversaries is a recipe for despair. I don’t need to recite polling or other data points because everyone knows in their bones that American self-confidence is at a low ebb.

Much of this is because the idea of America seems more contested and — however one defines it — more threatened than it has ever been. America has been divided specifically on the question of what the country means and is meant to be since the Founding itself, most violently during the middle 19th century. But what seems to be different now is that Americans simply cannot conceive of how others can think and feel the way they do about America in good faith.

Thus we see people saying that, for instance, only a person who wishes to destroy what is good and true about America would ever support or oppose Donald Trump. The contest over the American idea feels no longer like the working-out of a national compromise, in the way every dispute including the Founding itself but excluding the Civil War has been settled, but like an existential, even apocalyptic battle.

Yet in an otherwise red-meat partisan speech — exactly the kind of oratory that exacerbates the problem — JD Vance gestured toward a solution.

Advertise with us

What we share

If America really is only an idea, then it’s hard to see how the current battle over its meaning can be resolved. The civic muscles of compromise and compassion have atrophied, and there’s little will to exercise them again.

But no one actually experiences America only or even primarily as an idea. The things we live with and love about America on an everyday basis are tangible and particular, not abstract and general.

Even if we struggle to find common ground on the plane of ideas, we have the literal common ground of a land of beauty and abundance, along with the remarkable people who have stewarded it. We share the Badlands of Theodore Roosevelt and the Yosemite of John Muir.

But it doesn’t stop there. We share the Italian-born Frank Capra’s “It’s a Wonderful Life,” the Jewish Stanley Kubrick’s “Dr. Strangelove” and the Irish-Assyrian Terrence Malick’s “Days of Heaven.”

We share the D.C.-born Duke Ellington’s “Mood Indigo,” New York-born Aaron Copland’s “Fanfare for the Common Man” and New Mexico-born Henry John Deutchendorf Jr.’s “Country Roads” (guess where John Denver’s family was originally from).

Advertise with us

We share Hemingway and Whitman, Steinbeck and Fitzgerald, Faulkner and Baldwin, Dickinson and Twain. Other nations may be able to match or exceed the quality of literary output, but none can match the diversity of themes and styles.

But most of all we share neighbors and neighborhoods, an impossibly complicated web of relationships and connections that eventually bind us to all the peoples of the world — but which still bind us in a special way to the people who share the history and culture that is attached to this land.

Enter the story

So, I contend that JD Vance is right that America is a people and a homeland in addition to an idea.

Yet we must expand this formulation to say that America is, distinctively in the world of nations, an open and changing people who are defined by sharing a land, by participating in a dynamic culture that aggregates from the world’s cultures and, above all, by believing that America has something unique to offer the world — all while contesting what exactly that is.

Put more simply, America is the story of a growing people and our evolving relationship with a continental landscape and the idea of liberty.

Advertise with us

It is the story of jazz and Hollywood. It is the story of baseball and the National Parks. It is the story of complete bondage and incomplete liberation. It is the story of the frontier and the imperium.

It is a story with recurring themes of progress and industry and heroism and faith, but whose next page is never as predictable as you think.

It is one of the best national stories in history.

For those struggling to feel enthusiasm for America’s 250th birthday, what about meditating on the particular and tangible things you love about this country? What about your own families and neighborhoods and their stories, which are necessarily, distinctively American? What about your favorite landscapes and vistas, which are our shared American inheritance?

If there is to be a political renewal in America, this will be the foundation: a renewal of love and appreciation for the goods we share. Above all — we have a hell of a story.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pittsburgh thrives when its leaders act in a spirit of partnership.”